When someone dies due to another person's negligence or wrongful conduct, families often don't realize that New York law provides two separate legal pathways for seeking justice and compensation. While both wrongful death actions and survival actions arise from the same tragic circumstances, they serve fundamentally different purposes, benefit different parties, and address different types of harm. Understanding these distinctions is essential for families seeking a comprehensive legal remedy after losing a loved one.
Have You Lost A Loved One Because Of Someone's Negligence?
CONTACT USOur Recent Case Results
Settlement
Jury Verdict
Settlement
Settlement
At the Porter Law Group, we help families navigate both types of claims to ensure they recover all compensation available under New York law. Many families miss out on significant compensation because they don't understand that these are separate legal remedies that can often be pursued together. Here’s how these two types of actions differ—and why both may be crucial for your family’s case.
The Fundamental Difference: Who Benefits
The most important distinction between wrongful death and survival actions lies in who benefits from any compensation recovered:
Wrongful Death Actions compensate surviving family members for their losses resulting from the death. These cases focus on how the death has impacted the survivors financially and practically.
Survival Actions compensate the deceased person's estate for harm the deceased suffered between the time of injury and death. These cases focus on what the deceased person experienced and lost during their final period of life.
Understanding Wrongful Death Actions
Legal Foundation and Purpose
Under New York's Estates, Powers and Trusts Law Section 5-4.1, a wrongful death action addresses deaths occurring "as a result of a wrongful act, neglect, or default" where the deceased could have filed a personal injury lawsuit had they survived. The goal is to compensate surviving family members for the financial and practical losses caused by their loved one's death.
Who Can File and Who Benefits
Filing Requirements:
- Only the personal representative (executor) of the estate can file the lawsuit
- The action is brought for the benefit of the deceased's "distributees" (surviving family members)
- If an executor refuses to file, distributees can request that an administrator be appointed to pursue the claim
Primary Beneficiaries:
- Surviving spouse
- Children of the deceased
- Parents (when there are no surviving children)
- Other family members financially dependent on the deceased
Recoverable Damages in Wrongful Death Cases
New York's wrongful death law is restrictive, allowing only "pecuniary" (economic) damages:
Economic Losses:
- Lost earnings the deceased would have provided to the family
- Medical expenses incurred before death
- Funeral and burial costs
- Value of services the deceased provided (childcare, household maintenance, etc.)
- Loss of parental guidance for children (one of the few non-purely economic elements)
What's NOT Recoverable:
- Survivors' pain and suffering
- Grief, anguish, or emotional distress
- Loss of companionship or love
- Mental anguish experienced by family members
This limitation means that New York "perversely places a higher value on the lives of high-wage earners, over those who earn little or nothing – such as children, stay-at-home parents, and senior citizens."
Understanding Survival Actions
Legal Foundation and Purpose
Survival actions, governed by EPTL Section 11-3.2(b), allow the deceased person's estate to recover damages the deceased could have claimed if they had survived. The purpose is to ensure that wrongdoers cannot escape liability simply because their victim died, and to compensate for the harm the deceased person experienced before death.
Who Can File and Who Benefits
Filing Requirements:
- The estate’s personal representative must file the action
- The claim is brought on behalf of the deceased person's estate, not surviving family members
Who Benefits:
- The deceased person's estate receives any compensation
- Proceeds are distributed according to the deceased's will or New York intestacy laws
- Beneficiaries may differ from wrongful death beneficiaries
Recoverable Damages in Survival Actions
Survival actions focus on the deceased person's own experiences and losses:
Pain and Suffering:
- Physical pain experienced between injury and death
- Emotional distress and mental anguish of the deceased
- Fear, anxiety, and awareness of impending death
- Can be substantial if the person survived for an extended period
Economic Losses of the Deceased:
- Medical expenses for treatment of fatal injuries
- Lost wages during the period between injury and death
- Other economic losses personally suffered by the deceased
Punitive Damages:
- Available when defendant's conduct was particularly egregious
- Designed to punish wrongdoers and deter similar conduct
- Requires proof of willful disregard, malice, or gross negligence
Key Differences at a Glance
| Aspect | Wrongful Death Action | Survival Action |
| Purpose | Compensate survivors for their losses | Compensate for deceased's suffering |
| Beneficiaries | Surviving family members | Deceased's estate |
| Damages | Economic losses to survivors | Pain/suffering + deceased's losses |
| Pain & Suffering | NOT recoverable | YES, if deceased was conscious |
| Punitive Damages | Limited circumstances | Available for egregious conduct |
| Statute of Limitations | 2 years from death | 3 years from injury or 1 year from death |
Statute of Limitations: Critical Timing Differences
Wrongful Death Actions
- Standard Rule: 2 years from the date of death
- Medical Malpractice: 2.5 years from death
- 9/11 Related: 2.5 years from death
- Criminal Case Pending: At least 1 year after criminal case concludes
Survival Actions
- General Rule: 3 years from the date of injury
- Alternative Rule: 1 year from death (whichever is longer)
- Complex Timing: When someone survives initially but dies later from injuries
Critical Consideration: Because deadlines differ, families may lose one type of claim while still having time to pursue the other. This is why immediate legal consultation is essential.
Real-World Examples
Car Accident Scenario
Facts: A 40-year-old father is severely injured in a drunk driving accident. He survives for three weeks in intensive care, conscious and in severe pain, before dying from his injuries.
Wrongful Death Action:
- Filed by estate's personal representative
- Benefits: Wife and two children
- Damages: Lost future earnings ($2 million), funeral costs ($20,000), loss of parental guidance
- Total potential: $2,020,000+
Survival Action:
- Filed by same personal representative
- Benefits: Father's estate (then to family per will)
- Damages: Three weeks of severe pain and suffering ($200,000), medical bills ($150,000), lost wages during hospitalization ($6,000)
- Total potential: $356,000
Combined Recovery: Over $2.3 million vs. $2 million if only wrongful death pursued
Medical Malpractice Example
Facts: A 65-year-old retired grandmother dies from surgical malpractice after suffering for six months with complications.
Wrongful Death Action:
- Limited damages due to retirement (no lost earnings)
- Mainly funeral costs and some household services
- Potential: $75,000
Survival Action:
- Six months of pain, suffering, and awareness of declining health
- Extensive medical bills for attempted treatment
- Potential: $400,000+
Key Insight: Without the survival action, the family would have received minimal compensation despite clear malpractice.
Combining Both Actions
Practical Advantages
In most cases, both actions can and should be filed together:
Efficiency Benefits:
- Same factual circumstances and liability issues
- Reduced litigation costs
- Consistent findings on defendant's responsibility
- Single trial addressing all claims
Comprehensive Recovery:
- Addresses all aspects of harm caused
- Maximizes total compensation available
- Ensures nothing is overlooked or time-barred
Strategic Considerations
Evidence Overlap:
- Medical records support both types of damages
- Expert witnesses can address multiple issues
- Defendant's conduct relevant to both claims
Settlement Negotiations:
- Combined value creates stronger negotiating position
- Insurance companies must address full scope of liability
- Multiple damage categories provide settlement flexibility
Why Professional Legal Representation Is Essential
Complex Legal Analysis Required
Determining which actions to pursue requires:
- Detailed analysis of the deceased's final medical records
- Economic evaluation of various damage categories
- Strategic assessment of the strongest claims
- Coordination of multiple expert witnesses
Timing and Procedural Requirements
Critical Deadlines:
- Different limitation periods for each action
- Estate administration requirements
- Court approval processes for settlements
Procedural Complexity:
- Proper appointment of personal representatives
- Compliance with estate and probate requirements
- Coordination with criminal proceedings when applicable
Maximizing Recovery
Comprehensive Approach:
- Identifying all potential sources of compensation
- Engaging appropriate expert witnesses for each claim type
- Presenting compelling evidence of all categories of damages
- Negotiating with insurance companies who understand both claims
Both wrongful death and survival action cases are highly complex, requiring experience, legal expertise, and attention to detail. Our personal injury attorneys at the Porter Law Group have served the State of New York for over two decades, and have delivered substantial results for many grieving families. If your loved one suffered a wrongful death in New York, don’t hesitate to contact us for a free consultation to learn more about how you can recover the compensation you deserve.
Looking to File a Wrongful Death Claim in New York?
Reach out to our experienced team for a free consultation.
Why Choose the Porter Law Group
The lawyers at the Porter Law Group have decades of experience representing individuals and families whose lives have been devastated by catastrophic injuries. We have obtained some of the largest settlements and verdicts in courts throughout the State of New York. We are a state-wide firm that handles cases with a hometown feel.
Our clients come to us looking for guidance and answers. With seasoned trial lawyers, the Porter Law Group has the resources necessary to help you navigate the most complex cases, against goliath insurance companies that will stop at nothing to prevent you from receiving the compensation you deserve.
You only get one chance to hire the best lawyer for you and your family. Hire the lawyers most recommended by former clients and local attorneys, and the firm that obtains superior results.
When you or a loved one’s life has been devastated by a serious personal injury in New York, don’t hire a lawyer without calling the Porter Law Group to learn why so many of our clients are thankful they trusted us with their case in their time of need.
Take Action to Protect Your Rights
If you've lost a loved one due to someone else's negligence, you may be entitled to compensation through both wrongful death and survival actions. Time is critical, as different limitation periods apply to each type of claim.
Contact the Porter Law Group today at 833-PORTER9 or email info@porterlawteam.com for a free, no-obligation consultation. We'll evaluate your case, explain both types of potential claims, and help you understand the full scope of compensation available to your family.
Don't let insurance companies minimize your losses by focusing on only one type of claim. Our experienced wrongful death attorneys understand both legal remedies and work to maximize your family's total recovery.
Remember: your loved one's suffering matters, and your family's losses deserve full recognition under the law. Let us help you pursue comprehensive justice and compensation through all available legal avenues during this difficult time.
