Do Hospitals Pay Wrongful Death Claims Out of Court?

When a family loses someone due to medical negligence, one of the first questions that comes up is whether the hospital will actually go to court or if they'll settle the claim privately. The answer might surprise you. The overwhelming majority of these cases never see the inside of a courtroom.

Understanding how hospitals handle wrongful death claims can help you make informed decisions during an already devastating time. The reality is that hospitals and their insurance companies have well-established processes for resolving these claims, and most of the time, those processes happen behind closed doors rather than in front of a jury.

What the Numbers Tell Us About Hospital Settlements

The statistics paint a clear picture. More than 93% of all medical malpractice cases, including those involving wrongful death, are resolved through out-of-court settlements. Some studies put that number even higher, at around 96.5%, meaning only about 3 or 4 cases out of every 100 actually go to trial.

This isn't unique to any particular type of hospital or region. Whether you're dealing with a large academic medical center in Manhattan or a community hospital upstate, the pattern holds. Hospitals consistently choose to settle wrongful death claims rather than take their chances with a jury.

This high settlement rate doesn't mean hospitals are admitting fault in every case. It reflects a calculated business decision that considers legal costs, reputation management, and the unpredictability of jury verdicts. For families, it means there's a strong likelihood that any legitimate wrongful death claim will result in settlement negotiations at some point.

Why Hospitals Choose to Settle Rather Than Go to Trial

Hospitals have multiple reasons for preferring settlements over courtroom battles. The financial calculation goes beyond just the potential verdict amount.

Trials are expensive. Between attorney fees, expert witness costs, court fees, and the staff time required to prepare and attend trial, litigation costs can easily reach hundreds of thousands of dollars. A settlement negotiated early in the process eliminates most of these expenses for both sides.

Time is another major factor. Medical malpractice trials can take years from filing to verdict, especially in busy court systems. During that time, hospital administrators, doctors, and nurses may need to give depositions, review records, and potentially testify. This diverts attention from patient care and hospital operations. A settlement can resolve the matter in months rather than years.

Jury unpredictability weighs heavily on hospital decision-making. Even when a hospital believes it has a strong defense, there's no guarantee how a jury will respond to a grieving family presenting evidence of their loss. Juries can be sympathetic to families who lost loved ones, and verdicts can exceed what either side anticipated. Settlements allow hospitals to control their financial exposure.

Reputation matters in healthcare. A public trial means public testimony about what went wrong, potentially damaging media coverage, and a permanent court record of the allegations. Even if the hospital wins at trial, the publicity can affect patient trust and physician recruitment. Confidential settlements allow hospitals to resolve claims without the same level of public scrutiny.

Remember: Settlements do not automatically equal guilt. You may have heard the phrase "the process is the punishment". Whatever the possible outcome, reputation, time, and other resources will be spent by both parties (and the courts) during litigation. And these resources are conserved when parties are able to amicably resolve issues between themselves.

Courts also favor settlements, because they reduce the need for another new case in the docket, and give judges more time to address issues that may need more attention. But nobody can force you to settle. If you believe that you have a strong claim, or that the settlement offer is not justified, don't hesitate to reach out to an experienced personal injury attorney to ensure that your rights are protected.

Can You Sue a Hospital for Wrongful Death in New York?

Yes, you can sue a hospital in New York if medical negligence caused a family member's death. New York law recognizes wrongful death claims when someone dies due to another party's negligence, recklessness, or intentional actions.

To have a valid wrongful death claim against a hospital, you need to establish that medical negligence occurred and directly caused the death. This typically means proving that the hospital or its staff provided care that fell below accepted medical standards and that this substandard care led to your loved one's death.

Common situations that give rise to hospital wrongful death claims include:

• Surgical errors
• Medication mistakes
• Failure to diagnose serious conditions like heart attacks or strokes
• Infections acquired in the hospital
• Birth injuries that result in infant or maternal death
• Failures in monitoring patients who then deteriorate without intervention

The personal representative of the deceased person's estate must file the lawsuit. This is usually an executor named in a will or an administrator appointed by the court if there was no will. The compensation recovered goes to the estate and is distributed to eligible family members according to New York's wrongful death statute.

New York gives you two years from the date of death to file a wrongful death lawsuit. This deadline is strict, and missing it typically means losing your right to pursue compensation. However, the settlement process often begins well before any lawsuit is filed, with families or their attorneys sending demand letters to hospitals and their insurers.

How Much Do Hospitals Pay in Wrongful Death Settlements?

The compensation in wrongful death settlements varies dramatically based on the specific circumstances of each case. There's no standard payout or formula that applies across the board.

New York doesn't cap damages in medical malpractice or wrongful death cases. This distinguishes New York from many other states that limit how much families can recover. The absence of caps means settlements and verdicts are based on the actual damages proven in each case rather than an arbitrary legal limit.

Looking at settlement data across medical malpractice cases involving death, the average payout is around $380,000. However, this average doesn't tell the whole story because it includes cases with relatively modest settlements and cases worth millions of dollars.

More typical medical malpractice settlements range from $250,000 to $750,000 for cases with moderate damages. These might involve older patients, cases where negligence is less clear-cut, or situations where the financial impact on surviving family members is limited.

Catastrophic cases involving younger patients, clear negligence, and significant financial losses can result in settlements ranging from several million to over $20 million. Birth injury cases that result in infant death, for instance, have settled for amounts across this entire spectrum depending on the circumstances.

Several factors influence settlement amounts:

The age of the deceased matters significantly because younger people typically have more years of potential earnings and family contributions ahead of them.

The deceased person's income and earning capacity directly affect the economic damages calculation. The strength of the medical evidence showing negligence plays a major role in what hospitals are willing to pay.

The number and ages of dependents who relied on the deceased affects the compensation for loss of support.

The severity and obviousness of the medical error influences settlement negotiations, with clear-cut mistakes generally leading to higher settlements.

New York is a high-payout state for medical malpractice. In 2019, New York had the highest total medical malpractice payouts in the country at $661 million. This reflects both the state's large population and healthcare system, as well as the absence of damage caps that limit recovery in other states.

What Happens During Settlement Negotiations

The settlement process typically begins before any lawsuit is filed, though it can occur at any stage of litigation. Understanding how this process works can help you know what to expect.

Initial demand letters often start the conversation. After investigating the case and gathering medical records, an attorney will typically send a detailed demand letter to the hospital and its insurance carrier. This letter outlines what happened, explains why the hospital is liable, describes the damages suffered by the family, and proposes a settlement amount.

Insurance companies handle most settlement discussions. Hospitals carry medical malpractice insurance, and the insurance company's lawyers and claims adjusters typically manage the settlement negotiations. The hospital itself may have input on settlement decisions, but the insurer usually controls the process.

Back and forth negotiations follow the initial demand. The insurance company will almost never accept the first settlement demand. They'll typically respond with a much lower offer or a denial. This begins a negotiation process where both sides exchange offers and counteroffers, each side presenting evidence and arguments to support their position.

Medical experts play a crucial role in settlement leverage. Both sides will have doctors review the case to provide opinions on whether negligence occurred and whether it caused the death. Strong expert opinions supporting your case give you significant leverage in negotiations. Weak or conflicting expert opinions may lead to lower settlement offers.

Mediation is often used to facilitate settlements. Many cases go through formal mediation, where a neutral third party (often a retired judge or experienced attorney) helps both sides negotiate. Mediation is non-binding, but it often results in settlements because it forces both sides to seriously evaluate their positions.

Discovery can push settlements forward. Once a lawsuit is filed, both sides can request documents, take depositions, and gather evidence through the discovery process. As more information comes to light, both sides get a clearer picture of the case's strengths and weaknesses. This often leads to more realistic settlement negotiations.

Settlements can happen at any time. Some cases settle within months of the initial demand. Others settle on the courthouse steps just before trial. Still others settle during trial after the jury has been selected but before a verdict. There's no typical timeline because each case follows its own path.

Real Cases Show the Range of Outcomes

Looking at actual wrongful death settlements and verdicts helps illustrate how these cases resolve in practice.

A 59-year-old man died from prostate cancer that wasn't diagnosed in time. His family settled with the hospital for $1.25 million. The settlement reflected the delayed diagnosis that prevented timely treatment, though the patient's age and limited remaining work years affected the amount.

A 20-year-old with sickle cell anemia received improper treatment at a hospital, leading to complications and death. The family received a $700,000 verdict after trial. This case actually went to trial rather than settling, demonstrating that not every case resolves out of court, though this remains the exception.

A five-year-old girl died after doctors misdiagnosed tuberculosis meningitis as a less serious condition. The family settled for $8.6 million. The high settlement reflected the child's young age, the clear diagnostic error, and the decades of life she lost.

A woman suffered cardiac arrest due to misdiagnosed heart disease and was left in a permanent vegetative state before dying. Her family received a $6.33 million verdict. The extended suffering before death and the clear failure to recognize cardiac symptoms contributed to the substantial award.

There is typically some level of confidentiality involved in settlements. There are also bars for suing based on the cause of action once a settlement is agreed upon. But these cases show that settlement amounts depend heavily on the specific facts. Age, clarity of the negligence, and the strength of evidence all played roles in these outcomes. A good personal injury attorney is essential to ensure that you get the best settlement possible, and that you are not getting lowballed during the negotiations.

How Settlements Are Actually Paid

Once a settlement is reached, families have options for how they receive the money. The payment structure can significantly affect the financial impact on your family.

Lump sum payments are the most straightforward option. The hospital or its insurer writes a single check for the entire settlement amount (minus attorney fees and costs). You receive the money all at once and can use it as needed. This gives you immediate access to funds and complete control over the money.

Structured settlements spread payments over time. Instead of one large payment, you receive scheduled payments over months or years. These might be monthly payments, annual payments, or payments triggered by specific events or dates. Structured settlements can provide long-term financial security and may have tax advantages in some situations.

Families can often express preferences during settlement negotiations. If you need money immediately for expenses, you can push for a lump sum. If you prefer steady income over time, you can request a structured settlement. The hospital's insurer may have preferences too, but there's usually room for negotiation on payment terms.

Attorney fees come out of the settlement. Most wrongful death attorneys work on contingency, meaning they take a percentage of the recovery (typically one-third) plus reimbursement for case expenses. This is deducted from the settlement before you receive payment. Your attorney should clearly explain the fee arrangement and how much you'll actually receive.

Understanding Why Most Families Choose to Settle

Given that you have the right to take a hospital to trial, why do so many families choose to settle instead? The reasons are practical and emotional.

Trials extend the grieving process. Going through a trial means reliving your loved one's death in detail, often multiple times. You'll need to give depositions, review medical records, and potentially testify in court. For many families, settlement allows them to resolve the legal matter and focus on healing.

Settlements provide certainty. When you settle, you know exactly what compensation you'll receive. Trials are unpredictable. Even strong cases can result in defense verdicts, leaving families with nothing after years of litigation. Settlement eliminates that risk.

The time difference is substantial. Settlements typically resolve cases in months to a year or two. Trials can take three to five years or longer from filing to verdict, and even longer if there are appeals. Families often need financial help sooner rather than later.

Privacy matters to many families. Trials are public proceedings. Anyone can attend, and court records are generally public. Settlements usually include confidentiality provisions that keep the details private. For families who want to avoid public attention, this is valuable.

Emotional exhaustion is real. The litigation process is draining. Settlement allows families to close this chapter and move forward. While no amount of money replaces a loved one, settlement provides financial security without the additional trauma of trial.

However, settlement isn't always the right choice. Some families want their day in court. They want a public acknowledgment of what happened and a jury's verdict holding the hospital accountable. If a hospital refuses to make a fair settlement offer, trial may be necessary to obtain just compensation. Your attorney can help you weigh these considerations for your specific situation.

What Affects Your Leverage in Settlement Negotiations

Not all cases settle for the same amounts, and understanding what gives you leverage can help you evaluate your situation more realistically.

Clear evidence of negligence is the single most important factor. If medical records clearly show that doctors missed obvious signs of a heart attack, ignored test results, or made a surgical error, you have strong leverage. When negligence is ambiguous or involves judgment calls, hospitals are less likely to offer substantial settlements.

Expert medical opinions shape negotiations. If respected physicians in the relevant specialty review your case and conclude that the care fell below standards, your case is much stronger. If experts disagree or if the hospital has strong expert support for its position, settlement becomes more difficult.

The deceased's age and circumstances matter significantly. Cases involving children or young adults typically have higher settlement values because of the many years of life lost. Cases involving elderly patients with limited life expectancy and serious pre-existing conditions often settle for less, even when negligence is clear.

Your willingness to go to trial affects offers. Hospitals and insurers know which attorneys regularly take cases to trial and which ones always settle. If they believe you're prepared to try the case, they're more likely to make reasonable offers. If they think you'll accept a low offer to avoid trial, they'll push for that outcome.

The jurisdiction where you file matters. Some counties in New York have reputations for plaintiff-friendly juries, while others are seen as more conservative. Hospitals factor this into settlement decisions. A case filed in a plaintiff-friendly venue may generate better settlement offers.

Timing can affect leverage. Early in a case, before the hospital has spent significant money on defense, there may be opportunities for reasonable settlements. As litigation progresses and both sides invest more resources, positions can harden. However, as trial approaches and the risk becomes real for both sides, settlement momentum often increases.

The Role of Hospital Insurance in Settlement Decisions

Understanding who actually pays settlements helps explain hospital behavior in these cases.

Medical malpractice insurance covers most settlements and verdicts. Hospitals carry substantial insurance policies specifically for medical malpractice claims. These policies typically cover millions of dollars per incident and have annual aggregate limits that can reach tens of millions.

Insurance companies control settlement decisions up to policy limits. The insurance carrier's lawyers handle the defense and make decisions about settlement offers. Hospitals have input, but the insurer generally calls the shots because they're paying the claim.

Policy limits affect settlement negotiations. If a case is worth more than the insurance policy covers, the hospital's own assets could be at risk. This creates complicated dynamics. Sometimes hospitals will contribute their own money beyond policy limits to settle cases and avoid trial. Other times, they'll refuse, forcing families to either accept the policy limits or go to trial seeking a larger verdict.

Multiple insurance policies may apply. Large hospitals often have primary insurance policies and excess or umbrella policies that provide additional coverage beyond the primary limits. Settlements exceeding primary policy limits may trigger these additional policies.

Insurance companies have different settlement philosophies. Some insurers settle cases relatively quickly to control costs. Others fight almost every case aggressively, believing this deters future claims. The insurance company defending your case can significantly affect the settlement process.

What Happens If Settlement Talks Fail

While most cases settle, some don't. Understanding what happens next helps you make informed decisions throughout the process.

Filing a lawsuit formalizes your claim. If settlement negotiations fail or the statute of limitations is approaching, your attorney will file a formal complaint in court. This document outlines your allegations and the legal basis for your claim.

Discovery begins after the lawsuit is filed. Both sides exchange documents, take depositions of witnesses and parties, and gather evidence. This process can take a year or more in complex cases.

Settlement discussions continue during litigation. Just because you filed a lawsuit doesn't mean settlement is off the table. Many cases settle during discovery as both sides learn more about the strengths and weaknesses of their positions.

Pre-trial motions may narrow the issues. Either side can file motions asking the judge to make legal rulings before trial. These might include motions to dismiss the case, motions to exclude certain evidence, or motions for summary judgment.

Trial preparation intensifies as the trial date approaches. Your attorney will prepare you to testify, line up expert witnesses, and develop trial strategy. This is when settlement pressure often increases because both sides face the reality of trial.

Trials in wrongful death cases typically last several days to several weeks. Both sides present evidence, examine witnesses, and make arguments. Then the jury deliberates and reaches a verdict.

Appeals can extend the process further. Either side can appeal an unfavorable verdict, potentially adding years to the case. This is another reason many parties prefer settlement over trial.

Are Looking to Secure a Settlement for a Personal Injury Case?

Get a free case review and value estimate from our experienced New York personal injury attorneys. No cost, no-obligation, confidential.

Contact Us

Summing It Up

Hospitals do pay wrongful death claims out of court, and they do so in the vast majority of cases. More than 90% of medical malpractice wrongful death claims settle without a trial verdict. This reflects practical realities for both hospitals and families.

For hospitals, settlements control costs, save time, limit publicity, and eliminate the unpredictability of jury verdicts. For families, settlements provide certainty, faster resolution, and avoid the emotional toll of trial. New York's lack of damage caps means settlements can be substantial when the facts support significant damages.

Settlement amounts vary widely based on the deceased person's age, the clarity of the negligence, the strength of the evidence, and the financial impact on surviving family members. Cases can settle for a few hundred thousand dollars or for many millions, depending on these factors.

The settlement process involves negotiation between attorneys, often with input from medical experts and sometimes with the help of mediators. It can happen before a lawsuit is filed or at any point during litigation. Payment can come as a lump sum or structured over time based on the family's needs and preferences.

Understanding that hospitals routinely settle these claims should give families confidence that pursuing a legitimate wrongful death claim doesn't necessarily mean years of litigation. While every case is different and some do go to trial, most families can expect settlement negotiations to be part of the process. An experienced wrongful death attorney can evaluate your case, handle negotiations, and ensure any settlement offer is fair given your circumstances.

If you've lost a loved one due to suspected medical negligence, speaking with a personal injury attorney early can help protect your rights and start the process toward resolution, whether that ultimately comes through settlement or trial.