When someone you love suffers a serious injury because of someone else's negligence, the ripples extend far beyond the physical harm. Your marriage changes. The person you built a life with might struggle to participate in activities you once shared. Intimacy may become difficult or impossible. The emotional support you relied on might feel diminished. These losses are real, and New York law recognizes them through something called loss of consortium.
Did Your Loved One's Injury Put a Strain on Your Relationship?
CONTACT USOur Recent Case Results
Settlement
Jury Verdict
Settlement
Settlement
Loss of consortium is a legal claim that acknowledges the profound impact an injury has on a marriage. While the injured spouse pursues compensation for their medical bills, lost wages, and pain and suffering, the uninjured spouse can seek damages for losing the companionship, affection, comfort, and partnership they once had. This isn't about putting a price tag on love. It's about recognizing that when one person in a marriage gets hurt, both people suffer.
What Does Loss of Consortium Actually Mean?
Loss of consortium refers to the deprivation of the benefits that come from a family relationship. In practical terms, it covers several aspects of what makes a marriage meaningful. The companionship you share with your spouse, the physical intimacy that's part of your relationship, the emotional support you provide each other, and even the everyday help with household tasks all fall under this umbrella.
When a serious injury disrupts these elements of your marriage, the law treats that disruption as a compensable harm. You're not just losing abstract concepts. You might be losing the partner who helped raise your children, the person you traveled with, your confidant during difficult times, or simply the companion who made daily life feel less lonely.
The injury doesn't have to eliminate these aspects of your relationship completely for a loss of consortium claim to exist. Even significant diminishment counts. If your spouse can no longer participate in activities you built your life around, if chronic pain makes them irritable and withdrawn, if physical limitations mean they can't contribute to household responsibilities the way they once did, these changes matter.
Can You Sue for Loss of Consortium in New York?
You can pursue a loss of consortium claim in New York, but only if you meet specific legal requirements.
The first and most fundamental requirement is that you must be legally married to the injured person at the time the injury occurred. New York law does not extend loss of consortium claims to unmarried partners, no matter how long you've been together or how committed your relationship is. Engaged couples, domestic partners, and long-term companions cannot file these claims. The law draws a bright line at legal marriage.
The timing of your marriage matters too. You must have been married when the injury happened. Getting married after the accident, even if you were together at the time of the injury, doesn't give you the right to file a loss of consortium claim for that injury.
Your claim is also what lawyers call derivative, which means it depends entirely on your spouse's personal injury case. If your spouse cannot prove that someone else's negligence caused their injury, your loss of consortium claim cannot proceed. The two claims are legally intertwined. You're essentially saying, "Because my spouse was injured due to someone else's fault, I've suffered losses in my marriage." Without the first part being true, the second part has no legal foundation.
What Injuries Qualify for Loss of Consortium Claims?
Not every injury supports a loss of consortium claim in New York. The injured spouse must meet what's called the "serious injury" threshold under New York Insurance Law. This requirement exists primarily in cases involving motor vehicle accidents, where New York's no-fault insurance system limits when injured people can sue for pain and suffering.
The serious injury threshold includes nine specific categories:
- Death;
- Dismemberment;
- Significant disfigurement;
- A fracture;
- Loss of a fetus;
- Permanent loss of use of a body organ, member, function or system;
- Permanent consequential limitation of use of a body organ or member;
- Significant limitation of use of a body function or system; or
- An injury/impairment that hinders a person from usual daily activities for at least 90 days (within the first 180 days following the accident).
That last category, often called the 90/180-day rule, means the injury must be severe enough that it prevents your spouse from performing substantially all of their normal daily activities for at least 90 days out of the first 180 days after the accident. Medical documentation proving this limitation is essential.
Outside of motor vehicle cases, such as medical malpractice, workplace accidents not covered by workers' compensation, or premises liability cases, the serious injury threshold may not apply. However, the injury still needs to be substantial enough to meaningfully impact your marital relationship for a loss of consortium claim to have value.
How Much is a Loss of Consortium Claim Worth?
There is no calculator, formula, or standard amount for loss of consortium damages in New York. Unlike medical bills or lost wages, which have specific dollar amounts attached to them, the value of companionship and intimacy is inherently subjective. What a jury decides is fair and reasonable compensation depends on the unique circumstances of your marriage and the specific ways the injury has affected your relationship.
Several factors influence how much a loss of consortium claim might be worth:
The quality and stability of your marriage before the injury matters significantly. A strong, loving marriage that gets disrupted by injury typically warrants higher damages than a troubled relationship that was already experiencing difficulties. Courts and juries consider how close you were, how much time you spent together, and how integral you were to each other's daily lives.
The ages of both spouses and your life expectancies play a role because they affect how long you'll experience these losses. A young couple who will spend decades dealing with the consequences of an injury faces a longer period of diminished companionship than an older couple. This doesn't mean older couples receive less compensation automatically, but duration is a consideration.
The specific ways the injury has changed your life together matter enormously. If you and your spouse were avid hikers and travelers, and the injury has made those activities impossible, that's a concrete loss. If your spouse was the primary caregiver for your children and can no longer fulfill that role, that affects both the emotional and practical aspects of your family life. If chronic pain has made your spouse irritable and distant, that emotional withdrawal represents a real change in your relationship.
The severity and permanence of the injury influence the value of your claim. Temporary injuries that eventually heal completely result in temporary losses. Permanent disabilities that will affect your marriage for the rest of your lives justify larger awards. Catastrophic injuries that completely transform your spouse's personality, abilities, and capacity to participate in married life typically result in substantial loss of consortium damages.
Documentation and testimony about your relationship before and after the injury help establish the extent of your losses. Your own testimony about how your daily life has changed, what you've lost, and how you've been affected emotionally carries weight. Testimony from family members and friends who have observed the changes in your marriage provides outside perspective. Medical records and expert testimony about the nature of your spouse's injuries and limitations help establish the foundation for your losses.
How Do You Prove Loss of Consortium?
Proving loss of consortium requires demonstrating both the existence of a strong marital relationship before the injury and the specific ways that relationship has been damaged. This isn't about airing private details of your marriage for no reason. It's about showing the court and jury what you've lost.
Your testimony is central to a loss of consortium claim. You'll likely need to describe your relationship before the injury, including the activities you shared, the emotional support you provided each other, the physical intimacy you enjoyed, and the partnership you built. Then you'll explain how the injury has changed these aspects of your marriage. This can be emotionally difficult, especially when discussing intimate details of your relationship, but it's necessary to help others understand your losses.
Your injured spouse's testimony also matters. They can corroborate your description of your relationship before the injury and acknowledge the ways they can no longer participate in your marriage the way they once did. Their perspective on how the injury has affected their ability to be a partner carries significant weight.
Testimony from people who know you both well can provide valuable outside perspective. Family members, close friends, and others who spent time with you before and after the injury can describe the changes they've observed. They might testify about how you used to interact as a couple, activities you shared, and how your dynamic has shifted since the injury.
Medical records and expert testimony establish the severity and permanence of your spouse's injuries. While these documents primarily support your spouse's personal injury claim, they also provide the foundation for your loss of consortium claim by showing why your spouse can no longer participate in your marriage the way they once did. A doctor can explain how chronic pain affects mood and relationships, how physical limitations restrict activities, or how cognitive injuries change personality and emotional capacity.
Evidence of your life together before the injury helps paint a picture of what you've lost. Photos and videos of activities you shared, travel you enjoyed, and happy moments together show the jury what your marriage looked like before the injury disrupted it. Documentation of shared hobbies, memberships in clubs or organizations you participated in together, and other evidence of your life as a couple all help establish what you had and what the injury has taken away.
How Does the Legal Process Work for Loss of Consortium Claims?
Loss of consortium claims in New York are filed as part of the same lawsuit as the injured spouse's personal injury case. You don't file a separate, independent lawsuit. Instead, your claim is added to your spouse's case, and both claims proceed together through the legal system.
This structure exists because your claim is derivative of your spouse's claim. Since your losses stem directly from your spouse's injury, and that injury must have been caused by someone else's negligence, it makes sense to handle both claims together. This approach also prevents duplicative litigation and ensures that all claims arising from a single incident are resolved at the same time.
Having both claims in one lawsuit means you need to act within the same timeframe. New York's statute of limitations for personal injury cases is generally two years from the date of the accident. This deadline generally applies to both your spouse's personal injury claim and your loss of consortium claim. If you miss this deadline, you lose the right to pursue compensation. There are limited exceptions to this rule, but you should never count on an exception applying to your case.
Because the claims are connected and subject to the same deadlines, it's beneficial to have one legal team handle both. An attorney representing your family can develop a coordinated strategy that presents both claims effectively. They can gather evidence that supports both your spouse's injury claim and your consortium claim, ensuring nothing falls through the cracks.
The discovery process, where both sides exchange information and gather evidence, covers both claims. Depositions, interrogatories, document requests, and other discovery tools will explore not just the injury and its medical consequences but also the impact on your marriage. You should expect to answer detailed questions about your relationship, which can feel invasive but is necessary to establish your claim.
Settlement negotiations typically address both claims together. When the defendant or their insurance company makes an offer to settle the case, that offer usually includes compensation for both your spouse's injuries and your loss of consortium. You and your spouse will need to decide together whether an offer is acceptable, since both claims are being resolved.
If the case goes to trial, the jury will hear evidence about both claims and will be asked to determine damages for each separately. The jury instructions will explain that they should consider your spouse's physical injuries, pain and suffering, and economic losses, and separately consider your losses of companionship, affection, and services. The verdict will specify how much is awarded for each claim.
What Happens if Your Spouse's Injury Claim Fails?
Because your loss of consortium claim is derivative, it stands or falls with your spouse's personal injury case. If your spouse cannot prove that someone else's negligence caused their injury, your consortium claim cannot succeed. If the defendant successfully argues that they weren't at fault, or that your spouse was entirely responsible for their own injury, both claims fail.
Similarly, if your spouse's injury doesn't meet the serious injury threshold in cases where that threshold applies, both the pain and suffering component of their claim and your loss of consortium claim are barred. Your spouse might still recover economic damages like medical expenses and lost wages, but you cannot pursue consortium damages.
This connection means that the strength of your spouse's underlying injury claim directly affects your ability to recover compensation. A weak liability case or an injury that doesn't clearly meet legal thresholds puts both claims at risk. This is one reason why having experienced legal representation matters so much. An attorney can evaluate whether your spouse's injury case is strong enough to support both claims before investing time and resources into pursuing them.
Can Insurance Companies Challenge Your Loss of Consortium Claim?
Insurance companies and defendants routinely challenge loss of consortium claims, often more aggressively than they challenge the underlying injury claim. Because these damages are subjective and don't come with receipts or bills, insurers may argue that your losses aren't as significant as you claim.
Common defense strategies include arguing that your marriage was already troubled before the injury. If the defense can show that you and your spouse were experiencing marital difficulties, considering separation, or had a distant relationship before the accident, they'll use that to minimize your damages. This is why the quality and stability of your pre-injury marriage matters so much.
Defendants might also argue that your spouse's injuries aren't as severe or permanent as claimed, which undermines both the personal injury claim and your consortium claim. If they can show that your spouse has recovered more function than you're acknowledging or that their limitations are less restrictive than you describe, it weakens your claim that the injury has significantly impacted your marriage.
Insurance companies may hire investigators or use social media to find evidence that contradicts your claims. If you post photos of activities that seem inconsistent with the losses you're claiming, or if investigators observe your spouse doing things that suggest they're less limited than claimed, the defense will use that evidence against both claims.
The defense might also argue that factors other than the injury have caused changes in your marriage. If you've experienced other significant life stressors, financial problems, or family issues since the injury, they may claim those factors, not the injury, are responsible for the deterioration of your relationship.
Why Do You Need an Attorney for Loss of Consortium Claims?
Loss of consortium claims add complexity to personal injury cases, and handling them effectively requires legal knowledge and experience. An experienced personal injury attorney can evaluate whether you have a viable claim based on the specific facts of your case, including the strength of your spouse's injury claim, the nature of your marriage, and the ways the injury has affected your relationship.
Gathering and presenting evidence for a consortium claim requires skill. Your attorney needs to tell your story in a way that helps a jury understand what you've lost without being overly sentimental or vague. They need to prepare you for testimony that may feel invasive or uncomfortable, and they need to present medical and expert evidence that supports your claim.
Valuing loss of consortium claims is more art than science. An experienced attorney understands what similar cases have been worth and can develop a reasonable range of damages to pursue. They can also advise you on whether settlement offers adequately compensate you for your losses or whether going to trial makes more sense.
Negotiating with insurance companies requires leverage and knowledge. Insurance adjusters know that loss of consortium claims are subjective and may offer lowball settlements hoping you'll accept less than your claim is worth. An attorney who has successfully handled these claims before knows how to negotiate effectively and when to push back against inadequate offers.
If your case goes to trial, having an attorney who can effectively present your claim to a jury makes an enormous difference. They'll know how to select jurors who will be sympathetic to your losses, how to present evidence in a compelling way, and how to argue for appropriate damages in closing arguments.
Get a Free Case Review
Learn about all your legal options and what damages you can recover from an experienced personal injury attorney.
Summing It Up
Loss of consortium recognizes that serious injuries don't just harm the injured person. They harm marriages and families. When your spouse suffers a significant injury because of someone else's negligence, you lose parts of your relationship that matter deeply. The companionship, intimacy, emotional support, and partnership that made your marriage meaningful may be diminished or gone entirely.
New York law allows legally married spouses to seek compensation for these losses, but only if the injured spouse has a valid personal injury claim and meets certain injury thresholds. The value of these claims varies widely based on your specific circumstances, the quality of your marriage before the injury, and the extent to which the injury has changed your relationship.
These claims require careful handling because they're subjective, deeply personal, and often aggressively challenged by insurance companies. The legal process involves sharing intimate details of your marriage and demonstrating losses that can't be measured with bills or receipts. But for couples whose lives have been fundamentally altered by someone else's negligence, loss of consortium claims provide a path to recognition and compensation for very real losses.
If your spouse has been seriously injured and your marriage has suffered as a result, understanding your rights under New York law is the first step toward seeking the compensation you deserve for what you've lost. Don't hesitate to contact the Porter Law Group for a free consultation, and know more about how you can claim damages for loss of consortium in your personal injury case. Call 833-PORTER9 or email info@porterlawteam.com to get started.
