In 2018 alone, 39 people tragically lost their lives due to dog bite incidents, and that doesn't account for those that were just injured. There are an average of 6,000 emergency department visits each year related to dog bites, underscoring the urgency and importance of this issue. Dog bites are a significant public health and safety concern in New York State, with the issue being more prevalent and serious than many might realize.
This high incidence rate of dog bites not only highlights the physical dangers posed by dog bites but also emphasizes the need for both victims and dog owners to have a clear understanding of the legal landscape surrounding these incidents.
For victims, this knowledge is crucial in seeking justice if you were injured in a dog bite accident. If you were injured in New York, contact our dog bite attorneys for a free, no-obligation consultation by calling 833-PORTER9.
What are New York's Dog Bite Laws?
Mixed Approach: "One-Bite Rule" and "Strict Liability"
New York State adopts a mixed approach to dog bite laws, combining elements of the "One-Bite Rule" and "Strict Liability." This dual approach impacts how dog bite cases are handled legally.
- One-Bite Rule: Under this rule, a dog owner may not be held liable for the first bite or attack by their dog, provided they had no prior knowledge of the dog's aggressive tendencies. This rule essentially gives a 'free pass' to the dog and its owner for the first incident. However, once a dog has demonstrated aggressive behavior, the owner is expected to take reasonable steps to prevent future incidents.
- Strict Liability: In contrast to the One-Bite Rule, strict liability holds dog owners accountable for any harm their dog causes, regardless of the dog's previous behavior. This aspect of the law applies particularly to medical and veterinary costs resulting from a dog bite or attack.
What is the Distinction Between the Two Legal Concepts for Dog Bites in New York?
The key distinction between these two legal concepts lies in the owner's knowledge and responsibility. The One-Bite Rule considers the owner's awareness of their dog's propensity for aggression, while strict liability focuses on the outcome of the dog's action, irrespective of the owner's prior knowledge.
In New York, the application of these rules can vary based on the specifics of each case. For instance, if a dog previously adjudicated as "dangerous" causes harm, the owner may face stricter consequences under strict liability. Conversely, if a dog with no history of aggression causes injury, the One-Bite Rule might apply, potentially absolving the owner of immediate liability.
Involved in a Dog Bite Incident?
Reach out to our team to know your legal options (free and non-obligatory).
What is Considered a 'Dangerous Dog' in New York?
In New York State, the criteria for classifying a dog as "dangerous" are specified under the Agriculture & Markets Law, Section 123. A dog may be deemed dangerous if it attacks or threatens to attack a person, companion animal, farm animal, or domestic animal.
The determination of a dog as dangerous is not taken lightly and involves a judicial hearing where clear and convincing evidence is required. The law provides specific scenarios under which a dog can be classified as dangerous, emphasizing the need for responsible ownership and awareness of a dog's behavior.
What are the Legal Implications for the Dog and the Owner Once Classified as Dangerous?
Once a dog is classified as dangerous, there are several legal implications for both the dog and the owner:
- Mandatory Measures: The court may order measures such as neutering or spaying the dog, microchipping, and possibly training and behavior all evaluations.
- Confinement and Restraint: The dog may be required to be securely confined and/or muzzled when in public.
- Liability Insurance: The owner might need to maintain a liability insurance policy for any injuries the dog may cause.
- Severe Penalties: In cases of serious injury or death caused by a dangerous dog, the owner could face substantial fines, and the dog could be ordered to be euthanized.
What are the Responsibilities and Liabilities of Dog Owners in New York?
In New York, a dog owner's liability is determined based on several factors:
- Knowledge of the Dog's Aggressiveness: If the owner knew or should have known about the dog's aggressive tendencies, they could be held liable for injuries caused by the dog.
- Failure to Control the Dog: Owners are liable if they negligently fail to control a reasonably dangerous dog, leading to injury.
- Violation of Local Laws: Owners can also be held liable if their failure to adhere to local animal control laws results in an injury.
What are the Responsibilities of the Dog Owner Following a Biting Incident?
Depending on local regulations, the owner may need to report the incident to local authorities. The owner might be responsible for covering medical and veterinary costs resulting from the incident.
The owner should take steps to prevent future incidents, which may include training, confinement, or rehoming the dog. Compliance with any court orders or legal requirements following the incident is also mandatory.
What Should You Do After A Dog Bite Incident in New York?
Victims of dog bites in New York State have several legal options to seek recourse:
- Identify the Dog Owner: The first step is to identify the dog owner and obtain their contact information. This is crucial for preserving the right to sue and for determining if rabies vaccinations are necessary.
- Seek Medical Attention: Immediate medical attention is essential, not only for health reasons but also for documenting the injuries, which is vital for any legal action.
- Report the Incident: Victims should report the dog bite to local authorities, such as the police department or local animal control. This step is crucial for legal documentation and may be required by local laws.
- Document Everything: Victims should document all details of the incident, including photographs of injuries, torn clothes, or any damaged property. Gathering witness statements and contact information is also important.
- Consult an Attorney: Consulting with a personal injury lawyer who understands dog bite cases can provide guidance on the potential outcomes and the best course of action.
The Role of Evidence and Documentation in Building a Case
Documenting the injuries through medical records is essential for proving the extent and impact of the bite. Photos of the injuries and the scene can provide visual proof of the incident and its severity.
Statements from witnesses can verify the victim's account of the incident. Official reports from authorities or animal control can lend credibility to the victim's claim.
Can a Dog Owner Escape Liability After a Dog Bite Incident?
There are certain situations where a dog owner in New York might not be held liable for a dog bite:
- Trespassing: If the victim was trespassing on the dog owner's property when bitten, the owner might not be held liable.
- Provocation: If the dog was provoked into attacking, the owner's liability might be reduced or eliminated.
- Attempting to break up a dog fight
- Inadvertently causing pain, such as stepping on a dog's tail
- Approaching and touching an unfamiliar dog
- Using a repellent spray on a dog for self-defense purposes
- Entering a dog's territory without permission
- Making sudden or threatening movements toward the dog
- Defending Its Home or Owner: If the dog was defending its home, owner, or puppies, the bite might be justified.
Seeking Compensation for a Dog Bite Injury?
Dog bite victims may need to navigate insurance policies and legal defenses. Our clients don't have to pay unless we win.
What are the Legal Defenses Available to Dog Owners in New York?
Dog owners can use several legal defenses in dog bite cases:
- Lack of Knowledge: The owner might argue they had no knowledge of the dog's aggressive tendencies.
- Reasonable Control: If the owner took reasonable steps to control the dog or prevent the incident, this could be a defense.
- Victim's Negligence: The owner might claim that the victim's negligence contributed to the incident.
What is the Statute of Limitations for Dog Bite Claims in New York?
Victims of dog bites in New York have three years from the date of the bite to file a lawsuit in civil court. This statute of limitations is critical because if a case is filed after this period, the court is likely to dismiss it, barring the victim from pursuing any legal remedy.
What are the Exceptions to the Statute of Limitations for Dog Bite Claims in New York?
While the three-year limit is generally strict, there are exceptions that can affect this timeframe:
- Minor Victims: If the victim is a minor, the statute of limitations may not begin until they reach the age of majority, allowing them more time to file a lawsuit.
- Discovery Rule: In some cases, if the injury or its extent was not immediately apparent, the statute of limitations may begin from the date the injury was discovered, rather than the date of the dog bite.
What is the Role of Insurance in Dog Bite Incidents in New York?
How Homeowners' Insurance Policies Might Cover Dog Bite Incidents
Homeowners' insurance in New York often includes liability coverage, which can extend to dog bite incidents. This coverage is crucial as it can protect homeowners from significant financial burdens arising from dog bites. Here are key points about how this insurance works:
- Liability Coverage: Homeowners' insurance typically covers liability for injuries that occur on the property, including dog bites. This means if a dog bites someone on the homeowner's property, the insurance may cover the resulting damages.
- Off-Property Incidents: The coverage isn't limited to incidents on the property. If a dog bites someone off the property, the homeowner's insurance might still cover the damages.
- No-Fault State: New York is a "no-fault" state for dog bites, meaning the insurance coverage applies regardless of who was at fault in the incident.
Limitations and Considerations in Insurance Coverage
While homeowners' insurance can provide coverage for dog bite incidents, there are limitations and considerations:
- Breed Restrictions
While some insurance policies may traditionally have restrictions based on the breed of the dog, New York law has specific provisions regarding this. Under N.Y. Ins. Law § 3421, insurers in New York are prohibited from refusing to issue, renew, or cancel a homeowners' insurance policy, or from charging an increased premium, based solely on the ownership of a dog of a specific breed or mixture of breeds. This law aims to prevent breed-specific discrimination in insurance policies.
However, it does allow insurers to take necessary actions, such as refusing to issue or renew, canceling a policy, or imposing a reasonably increased premium, in cases where a dog, regardless of its breed, has been declared dangerous as per Section 123 of the agriculture and markets law. These actions must be justified based on sound underwriting and actuarial principles related to actual or anticipated loss experience.
- Policy Limits
The amount of coverage available will depend on the specific policy limits. Higher costs exceeding the policy limit might not be covered.
- Exclusions
Incidents where the dog owner encouraged the dog to bite, or if the bite occurred during a business operation at home, might not be covered.
How are New York's Dog Bite Laws Different from Other States?
New York's dog bite laws differ from those in other states in several ways:
- Mixed Approach: New York uses a combination of the One-Bite Rule and Strict Liability, which is not as common in other states.
- Strict Liability for Medical Costs: Unlike some states that have a strict liability approach for all damages, New York's strict liability is often limited to medical and veterinary costs.
- No-Fault Insurance: New York's status as a no-fault state for dog bites is unique, offering broader insurance coverage for dog bite incidents.
Seeking Legal Assistance for Dog Bite Cases
If you or your loved ones have been affected by a dog bite incident in New York, the Porter Law Group is here to offer the support and guidance you need. Our team operates on a contingency basis, meaning there are no upfront fees for you. We prioritize the needs of those who have been injured, ensuring that your rights are protected and that you receive the compensation you deserve.
For assistance with dog bite claims in New York, contact us at 833-PORTER9 or email info@porterlawteam.com for a free consultation.
