Can I Sue If My Insurance Company Denied My Claim?

Finding out your insurance claim was denied feels like getting kicked when you're already down. You've been paying premiums, following the rules, and now when you actually need help, the company says no. It's frustrating, confusing, and leaves you wondering what to do next.

The short answer is yes, you can sue your insurance company in New York if they wrongfully denied your claim. But there's more to it than just filing a lawsuit. You'll need to understand the process, know what you're up against, and recognize that New York handles these cases differently than most other states.

How New York Treats Insurance Denials Differently

New York doesn't make it easy to sue insurance companies, and that's by design. Unlike most states, New York doesn't allow what's called a "bad faith" lawsuit against insurers. This matters more than you might think.

In many states, if an insurance company denies your claim unreasonably or treats you poorly during the process, you can sue them for acting in bad faith. That opens the door to punitive damages, compensation for emotional distress, and payment of your attorney fees. It's meant to punish insurers who play games with legitimate claims.

New York took a different approach. Here, you're generally limited to suing for breach of contract. That means you can recover what the policy should have paid you, but nothing extra. No punitive damages. No compensation for the stress of fighting with your insurer for months. No attorney fees unless your policy specifically includes them.

The state does have Insurance Law Section 2601, which prohibits unfair claim settlement practices. This law says insurers can't misrepresent policy terms, fail to investigate claims properly, or deny claims without reasonable basis. But here's the catch: this law doesn't give you the right to sue directly. It's enforced by state regulators, not through private lawsuits.

There's been proposed legislation (Senate Bill 3673 and Assembly Bill 7102) that would change this. The bills would let policyholders sue for compensatory, consequential, and punitive damages when denials lack substantial justification. Punitive damages would be capped at twice the covered loss, and you could recover attorney fees. But as of now, these bills remain pending in committee. They haven't passed.

Can You Sue Your Insurance Company for Denying Your Claim?

Yes, but you need to follow the rules first. Insurance policies almost always require you to exhaust the company's internal appeals process before you can file a lawsuit. If you skip this step and go straight to court, the judge will likely dismiss your case.

This requirement isn't just a technicality. It serves a purpose. It gives the insurance company a chance to correct mistakes, review additional evidence, and reconsider their decision. Many denials get overturned on appeal, especially when you provide documentation the company didn't have initially.

Failing to complete the appeals process doesn't just delay your case. It can kill it entirely. Courts take these requirements seriously, and insurers will absolutely use your failure to appeal as a defense.

What You Need to Do Before Filing a Lawsuit

Start with the internal appeal. Your denial letter should explain how to appeal and give you a deadline. Don't ignore this. Gather every piece of evidence that supports your claim and submit it with your appeal.

For medical claims, this might mean getting additional documentation from your doctor, medical records that show the severity of your condition, or expert opinions explaining why the treatment was necessary. For disability claims, you might need vocational assessments, detailed medical evaluations, or statements from your employer about your job requirements.

The insurance company will review your appeal and issue a decision. If they deny it again, you typically have the right to a second level of appeal. Use it. Each appeal creates a record of what the company knew, when they knew it, and how they responded. This becomes crucial evidence if you end up in court.

While you're going through appeals, file a complaint with the New York State Department of Financial Services. This won't directly overturn your denial, but it puts the insurer on notice that regulators are watching. It also creates an official record of their conduct, which can support your lawsuit later.

The DFS tracks complaints and investigates patterns of unfair practices. If enough people complain about the same issue, it can trigger regulatory action. Your complaint contributes to that oversight, even if it doesn't immediately resolve your problem.

Only after you've exhausted these steps should you consider filing a lawsuit. And pay attention to deadlines. Many policies include strict time limits for filing suit, often measured from the date of denial. Miss the deadline and you lose your right to sue, no matter how wrong the denial was.

Why Insurance Companies Deny Claims

Understanding why claims get denied helps you fight back more effectively. Some denials are legitimate. Others are questionable at best.

Pre-existing conditions are a common reason for denial, especially in disability and health insurance. The insurer argues that your current problem stems from a condition you had before coverage started. Sometimes they're right. Other times they're stretching the definition of "pre-existing" beyond recognition.

Insufficient documentation is another frequent excuse. The company claims you didn't provide enough medical records, didn't prove your disability prevents you from working, or didn't demonstrate the treatment was medically necessary. This often happens when they don't clearly tell you what documentation they need, then fault you for not providing it.

Policy exclusions and limitations catch many people off guard. You thought something was covered, but the policy has specific language excluding it. These exclusions can be buried in dense policy language that's hard to understand. Sometimes the exclusion is legitimate. Other times the company misapplies it to deny claims that should be covered.

Paperwork errors and missed deadlines give insurers easy grounds for denial. You filed the claim form wrong, missed a deadline you didn't know about, or failed to get pre-authorization for a procedure. These technical denials are frustrating because they don't address whether your claim has actual merit.

Some denials are more cynical. The company conducts an inadequate investigation, ignores evidence that supports your claim, or relies on their own hired experts who never examined you. They're betting you won't fight back, and unfortunately, they're often right.

What Types of Insurance Claims Can You Sue Over?

The answer depends on what kind of insurance denied your claim. The basic principle is the same across all types (breach of contract), but the specifics vary.

Long-term disability insurance denials are particularly common and particularly contentious. Companies like New York Life and others frequently deny claims based on inadequate medical examinations, narrow interpretations of what qualifies as a disability, or arguments that you can still do some type of work, even if not your actual job.

These cases often turn on detailed medical evidence and vocational assessments. The insurer will have you examined by their own doctors, who somehow always seem to conclude you're not disabled. Fighting back requires strong documentation from your treating physicians and sometimes your own independent medical experts.

Life insurance denials typically involve policy exclusions, questions about the cause of death, or allegations that the policyholder made misrepresentations on the application. New York law requires insurers to pay life insurance claims promptly after receiving proof of death. Delays or denials without valid reason can support a breach of contract claim.

These cases sometimes involve interstate issues. If the policy was issued in another state or includes a forum selection clause, you might end up litigating somewhere other than New York. This can complicate matters, especially regarding which state's laws apply.

Auto and personal injury claims under your own insurance policy face unique hurdles in New York because of the state's no-fault system. You can only sue for non-economic damages like pain and suffering if you meet the "serious injury" threshold. This requires proving your injury falls into specific categories defined by law.

If your own insurance company denies coverage for your injuries or undervalues your claim, you can sue for breach of contract. But you'll need solid medical documentation proving the severity of your injuries. The insurer will scrutinize everything, looking for pre-existing conditions, gaps in treatment, or evidence that your injury isn't as serious as you claim.

Property and homeowners insurance denials often involve disputes over the cause of damage, the value of what was lost, or whether specific perils are covered. These cases require documentation of the damage, proof of value, and evidence that the loss falls within policy coverage.

Health insurance denials can be challenged, but the process is heavily regulated. You have specific appeal rights under both state and federal law, and you must exhaust them before suing. Many health insurance disputes involve questions about medical necessity, whether treatment is experimental, or whether providers are in-network.

Using General Business Law Section 349 as a Workaround

Since New York doesn't allow bad faith insurance lawsuits, creative lawyers have found a workaround through General Business Law Section 349. This law prohibits deceptive consumer practices and does allow for private lawsuits.

To win under Section 349, you need to prove three things:

• First, the insurer's conduct was consumer-oriented, meaning it affected the public broadly, not just you individually.
• Second, the conduct was materially deceptive or misleading.
• Third, you were injured as a result.

Courts have applied this to insurance denials when there's evidence of systematic problems. If the company has a pattern of denying certain types of claims, using misleading policy language, or training adjusters to minimize payouts, that might support a Section 349 claim.

The advantage of Section 349 is that it allows for attorney fees and potentially broader damages than a simple breach of contract claim. The disadvantage is that it's harder to prove. You need evidence of a pattern, not just a single wrongful denial.

Some courts use Insurance Law Section 2601 as the standard for what counts as deceptive. If the insurer violated those unfair practices provisions, that can establish the deception element of a Section 349 claim. But this is a developing area of law, and not all judges agree on how broadly to apply it.

What You Can Actually Recover in a Lawsuit

In a breach of contract case, you can recover the benefits the policy should have paid. If you had a disability policy that should have paid you $5,000 per month and they denied it for two years, you can sue for the $120,000 in missed payments.

You can also recover interest on the unpaid amount. New York law provides for interest on money judgments, which can add up over time, especially if the denial happened years ago.

What you typically can't recover are consequential damages. These are the ripple effects of the denial. Maybe you lost your home because you couldn't pay the mortgage without your disability benefits. Maybe you couldn't afford medical treatment and your condition worsened. Maybe the stress of fighting the insurance company affected your health.

In most cases, you can't recover for these harms in a breach of contract action. The insurer only owes you what the policy promised, not compensation for everything that went wrong because they didn't pay.

You also can't recover punitive damages designed to punish the insurer for bad behavior. You can't recover your attorney fees unless the policy specifically provides for them or you win under a theory like Section 349 that includes fee-shifting.

This is why the proposed legislation to allow bad faith claims matters so much. It would fundamentally change what's at stake in these cases and create real consequences for insurers who wrongfully deny claims.

Time Limits You Need to Know About

Time limits can kill your case before it starts. New York's statute of limitations for breach of contract claims is generally six years. That sounds like plenty of time, but many insurance policies include much shorter deadlines for filing suit.

It's common to see policy provisions requiring you to sue within three years of the denial, two years, or even less. These contractual limitations are often enforceable, meaning the six-year statute of limitations doesn't help you if your policy says three years.

The clock typically starts running from the date of denial, not from when you finish the appeals process. This creates a squeeze. You need to exhaust appeals before suing, but the deadline for filing suit might expire while you're still appealing.

Pay close attention to the deadlines in your denial letter and policy documents. If you're getting close to a deadline and still going through appeals, consult with an attorney about whether you need to file suit to preserve your rights, even if you haven't finished the administrative process.

Missing these deadlines is one of the most common reasons insurance cases fail. The merits don't matter if you're too late to bring the claim.

The Evidence That Actually Matters

Insurance companies have resources, experience, and lawyers on retainer. They know how to defend these cases. Winning requires solid evidence, not just a sense that you were treated unfairly.

Medical records are the foundation of most disability and health insurance disputes. You need complete records that document your diagnosis, treatment, limitations, and prognosis. Gaps in treatment hurt your case. If you stopped seeing doctors for six months, the insurer will argue you weren't really disabled.

Expert opinions often make or break these cases. The insurer will have their doctors who say you're fine. You need your own experts who can explain why you're not. This might mean independent medical examinations, vocational assessments showing you can't work, or specialists who can testify about your condition.

Policy language matters more than you might think. These cases often turn on interpreting specific terms in the policy. What does "totally disabled" mean? What counts as "medically necessary"? What's included in "covered expenses"? Small differences in wording can change the outcome.

Documentation of your communications with the insurer can be crucial. Save every letter, email, and claim form. Take notes after phone calls, including who you spoke with, when, and what was said. This creates a record of what information they had, what they told you, and how they handled your claim.

For property claims, you need documentation of the damage and its value. Photos, repair estimates, receipts, and appraisals all help prove your case. For life insurance, you might need death certificates, medical records, and documentation about the circumstances of death.

The more evidence you have, the harder it is for the insurer to defend their denial. They're counting on you not having complete documentation. Prove them wrong.

Why These Cases Are Hard to Win on Your Own

Insurance companies aren't individuals who made a mistake. They're corporations with legal departments, established procedures, and experience defending these claims. They know the law, they know the process, and they know how to make it difficult for you.

They'll exploit any weakness in your case. Incomplete medical records, gaps in treatment, inconsistent statements, missed deadlines. They have lawyers who do nothing but defend these cases, and they're good at it.

The legal issues can be complex. Policy interpretation involves technical rules of contract law. Proving a Section 349 claim requires understanding consumer protection statutes and how courts apply them. Procedural requirements like exhausting appeals and meeting filing deadlines create traps for the unwary.

You're also dealing with your own injury, disability, or loss while trying to fight a legal battle. That's a lot to handle, especially when you're already struggling with whatever problem led you to file the claim in the first place.

Insurance defense lawyers know most people will give up. The process is designed to be exhausting. Appeals take months. Lawsuits take years. Many people simply can't sustain that fight without help.

An experienced attorney levels the playing field. They know what evidence you need, how to build your case, and how to counter the insurer's defenses. They understand the procedural requirements and deadlines. They can handle the legal work while you focus on your recovery.

Attorneys also typically work on contingency in these cases, meaning they only get paid if you win. That makes legal representation accessible even when you're financially struggling because of the denied claim.

What Happens During the Lawsuit Process

It starts with filing a complaint that lays out your case. You explain what the policy promised, how the insurer breached it, and what damages you're seeking.

The insurance company responds with an answer, usually denying everything and raising various defenses. They might argue the denial was proper, you didn't exhaust appeals, you missed deadlines, or the policy doesn't cover what you claim.

Discovery follows. This is the process of exchanging information and evidence. You'll provide medical records, employment records, financial documents, and answers to written questions. You might have to give a deposition where the insurer's lawyer questions you under oath.

The insurer will provide their claim file, which shows what they knew and when, what investigation they did, and why they made the decision to deny. This file often contains helpful evidence for your case, including documents showing they ignored evidence or applied the policy incorrectly.

Expert witnesses become important during this phase. Both sides might hire doctors, vocational experts, or other specialists to support their position. These experts will review records, examine you, and provide opinions about your condition and limitations.

Many cases settle during or after discovery. Once both sides see the evidence, they can better evaluate the strengths and weaknesses of their positions. The insurer might realize their denial was shaky. You might realize certain aspects of your claim are weak.

If the case doesn't settle, it goes to trial. A judge or jury will hear evidence, listen to witnesses, and decide whether the insurer breached the contract and what you're owed. Trials are expensive, time-consuming, and unpredictable. Both sides usually prefer to settle if possible.

The timeline varies widely. Simple cases might resolve in a year. Complex cases can take three years or more. Appeals can add additional time.

Were You Wrongfully Denied an Insurance Claim?

Get a free case evaluation form our experienced personal injury attorneys and know your next best options.

Contact Us

Summing It Up

Getting your insurance claim denied doesn't mean you're out of options. You can sue your insurance company in New York, but you need to follow the process and understand the limitations.

Start by exhausting the internal appeals process. Gather strong evidence, submit complete documentation, and use every level of appeal available. File a complaint with the Department of Financial Services to create an official record.

If appeals fail, consult with an attorney before the deadline for filing suit expires. These cases are difficult to win on your own, and the insurance company has significant advantages in resources and experience.

Understand that New York limits you to breach of contract claims in most cases. You can recover the benefits you're owed, but probably not punitive damages, attorney fees, or compensation for consequential harms unless you can prove a deceptive practices claim.

Pay attention to deadlines. Insurance policies often require you to sue within a specific timeframe, and missing that deadline ends your case regardless of the merits.

Document everything. Save all communications with the insurer, keep complete medical records, and gather evidence that supports your claim. The more documentation you have, the stronger your case.

The fact that New York makes it harder to sue insurance companies than most states doesn't mean you're powerless. It just means you need to be strategic, thorough, and persistent. Many wrongfully denied claims do eventually get paid, either through appeals, settlement, or litigation.

If you've been paying premiums and following the rules, you deserve the coverage you paid for. Don't let a denial letter be the end of the story.