New York shoulder dystocia injury claims generally must be filed before the child's 10th birthday under CPLR §214-a and CPLR §208. Every settlement requires judicial approval at an infant compromise hearing under CPLR §1207 and §1208, and attorney fees follow the sliding scale in Judiciary Law §474-a. According to ACOG Practice Bulletin No. 178 (May 2017), shoulder dystocia is an "unpredictable and unpreventable" obstetric emergency that occurs in approximately 0.6% to 1.4% of vaginal deliveries in the data ACOG synthesizes, with peer-reviewed studies reporting incidences ranging up to approximately 3% in some populations, and a 2024 NIH StatPearls review confirms incidence rises sharply with infant birth weight — approximately 1% for infants under 4,000 g, 5% for infants 4,000–4,500 g, and 9–10% for infants over 4,500 g. The negligence in shoulder dystocia cases is rarely in failing to predict the emergency — it is in the response. Porter Law Group represents New York families whose children sustained preventable injuries because the obstetric team failed to follow the published shoulder dystocia management standard of care.
Settlement
Jury Verdict
Settlement
Settlement
Shoulder dystocia cases turn on the delivery-room documentation, what maneuvers were performed, in what order, by whom, with what timing, and what force was applied. ACOG explicitly recommends contemporaneous documentation of every shoulder dystocia event, and when that documentation reveals the team applied excessive lateral traction or used fundal pressure instead of the McRoberts-first sequence, the case for malpractice is generally strong. Porter Law Group has recovered more than $500 million for seriously injured clients since 2009, including multiple pediatric recoveries exceeding $8 million for children with permanent delivery-related disabilities.
Led by Harvard-educated attorney Michael S. Porter, a former U.S. Army JAG Corps Captain with over 20 years of trial experience, the firm retains maternal-fetal medicine specialists, pediatric neurologists, pediatric orthopedic and neurosurgeons, and life care planners to document the mechanism of injury and the cost of a lifetime of therapy, orthotic care, and reconstructive surgery. Seven of eight partner-level attorneys are recognized by Super Lawyers, a distinction earned by fewer than 5% of New York attorneys.
"Shoulder dystocia itself is not malpractice, ACOG calls it an unpredictable and unpreventable emergency. The malpractice is in the response. Did the team announce the dystocia and call for help? Did they start with McRoberts? Did they apply suprapubic pressure rather than fundal pressure? Did they track the head-to-body interval? Did they avoid aggressive lateral traction? The chart almost always tells us whether the published standard of care was followed or whether someone panicked and pulled too hard."
— Michael S. Porter, J.D., Porter Law Group
REQUEST A NO-OBLIGATION CASE REVIEW
Shoulder dystocia is an obstetric emergency in which, after delivery of the fetal head, normal traction fails to deliver the shoulders because the anterior shoulder becomes impacted behind the mother's pubic symphysis (or, less commonly, the posterior shoulder behind the sacral promontory). Per ACOG Practice Bulletin No. 178 (May 2017), shoulder dystocia occurs in approximately 0.6% to 1.4% of vaginal deliveries in the data ACOG synthesizes, with peer-reviewed studies reporting incidences ranging up to approximately 3% in some populations . The Royal College of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists Green-top Guideline No. 42 (2012) proposes an objective diagnosis when the head-to-body delivery interval exceeds 60 seconds, though this data is not routinely collected.
Incidence rises sharply with fetal size. Per a 2024 NIH StatPearls review:
| Infant Birth Weight | Shoulder Dystocia Incidence |
| Under 4,000 g (under 8 lbs 13 oz) | Approximately 1% |
| 4,000–4,500 g (8 lbs 13 oz to 9 lbs 15 oz) | Approximately 5% |
| Over 4,500 g (over 9 lbs 15 oz) | Approximately 9–10% |
ACOG and the AAFP identify recognized risk factors that elevate the probability of shoulder dystocia but do not reliably predict it: fetal macrosomia, maternal pre-pregnancy or gestational diabetes, prior shoulder dystocia, operative vaginal delivery (vacuum or forceps), prolonged second stage of labor, and post-term pregnancy. A 2020 American Academy of Family Physicians review emphasizes that "most cases occur without warning" — meaning labor and delivery teams must be prepared to recognize and manage the emergency in any delivery.
The emergency itself is generally not preventable. The negligence in shoulder dystocia litigation is almost always in the response, not in failing to anticipate the event.
Per ACOG Practice Bulletin No. 178 (May 2017), the recognized management sequence — endorsed jointly by ACOG, the Royal College of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists, and the Advanced Life Support in Obstetrics (ALSO) program — is:
ACOG also recommends contemporaneous documentation of every shoulder dystocia event, including the head-to-body interval, every maneuver performed, the order of maneuvers, the personnel involved, and the resulting newborn condition. Simulation training is recommended because it has been shown to reduce the incidence of brachial plexus palsy associated with shoulder dystocia. Failure to document, failure to attend simulation training, and failure to follow the published management sequence each provide a discrete basis for malpractice analysis.
Shoulder dystocia can cause both fetal and maternal injuries. The fetal injuries are generally the basis for birth injury litigation:
| Type of Injury | Mechanism | Linked Practice Area |
| Brachial plexus injury (Erb's palsy, Klumpke palsy, total plexus palsy) | Excessive lateral traction on the fetal head while the shoulder is impacted | Brachial Plexus |
| Clavicle and humerus fractures | Mechanical force during delivery; sometimes intentionally induced to disimpact the shoulder | Shoulder Injury |
| Hypoxic-ischemic encephalopathy (HIE) | Prolonged head-to-body delivery interval with cord compression and oxygen deprivation | HIE |
| Cervical spinal cord injury | Hyperextension and rotation during dystocia management | Spinal Cord |
| Cerebral palsy | Long-term consequence of HIE in catastrophic dystocia cases | Cerebral Palsy |
| Wrongful death | Catastrophic dystocia with prolonged hypoxia or maternal hemorrhage | Wrongful Death |
Maternal injuries can include postpartum hemorrhage from uterine atony, third- and fourth-degree perineal lacerations, symphyseal separation, and transient femoral neuropathy — particularly when the McRoberts maneuver is held for extended periods.
Because ACOG explicitly classifies shoulder dystocia itself as "unpredictable and unpreventable," the malpractice analysis focuses almost entirely on the response. Three failure patterns recur:
Failure 1 — Excessive lateral traction on the fetal head. This is the most common malpractice mechanism. When the chart shows aggressive downward or lateral traction on the fetal head — often documented as the clinician trying to "deliver the shoulder" before performing recognized maneuvers — the resulting brachial plexus injury or skull or cervical injury is generally actionable.
Failure 2 — Fundal pressure instead of suprapubic pressure. Fundal pressure (force applied to the top of the uterus) is contraindicated in shoulder dystocia. It does not disimpact the shoulder and has been linked to brachial plexus injuries and skeletal fractures. When the chart documents fundal pressure during a dystocia, it is a recognized deviation from the standard of care.
Failure 3 — Failure to follow the McRoberts-first sequence or to call for help. The published management sequence under ACOG Practice Bulletin No. 178 is McRoberts → suprapubic pressure → posterior arm delivery or internal rotation. Skipping steps, going directly to instrument-assisted delivery, or attempting forceful delivery without first attempting these recognized maneuvers is a recognized basis for malpractice.
In addition, two pre-emergency failures can establish liability:
New York places no statutory cap on damages in medical malpractice or birth injury cases. The damages depend on the resulting injury — most often a brachial plexus injury or, in catastrophic cases, hypoxic-ischemic brain damage.
Future medical and surgical care. For brachial plexus injuries with permanent deficit, the treatment pathway includes physical and occupational therapy, primary nerve surgery (typically at 6–12 months), secondary reconstructive procedures, and lifelong orthotic care. Life care plans routinely project millions of dollars. For HIE-to-cerebral-palsy cases, lifetime care projections frequently exceed $10 million — the CDC estimates the lifetime cost of care for an individual with cerebral palsy at approximately $1 million in 2003 dollars, with medical costs running roughly 10 times higher than for children without CP.
Lost future earning capacity. A child with permanent dominant-arm weakness or with cognitive impairment from HIE can recover the full projected lifetime earnings of a comparable uninjured peer, projected from parental educational background and U.S. Census earnings data.
Pain and suffering damages are not capped in New York. Juries consider the permanence of the injury, the child's life expectancy, and the loss of normal childhood, adolescent, and adult experiences.
Wrongful death. Catastrophic shoulder dystocia with prolonged hypoxia can result in stillbirth or neonatal death; parents may pursue a wrongful death claim under EPTL §5-4.1 within two years of the death.
Parents' derivative claim. Parents can recover medical expenses they paid on the child's behalf and damages for loss of the child's services — but under their own 2.5-year CPLR §214-a statute, which is not tolled by the child's infancy.
FIND OUT WHAT YOUR CHILD'S SHOULDER DYSTOCIA CASE IS WORTH →
Porter Law Group's published results include 53 cases at or above $1 million, with multiple pediatric recoveries exceeding $8 million. View all case results →
$8,300,000 Settlement: A premature infant suffered profound permanent disabilities, including cerebral palsy, after physicians failed to properly manage the mother's pre-gestational diabetes — a recognized risk factor for fetal macrosomia and shoulder dystocia. The structured settlement provides lifetime care and therapy funding.
$8,250,000 Settlement: An infant sustained permanent physical and cognitive disabilities after delayed response to fetal distress during labor. Proceeds covered lifetime medical and educational needs.
$8,120,000 Settlement: An infant suffered permanent delivery-related injuries caused by mismanaged labor and delivery. The recovery funded a life-care plan built with the family's physicians and therapists.
Every case is different. Past results do not guarantee future outcomes.
Shoulder dystocia injury claims are medical malpractice cases, so the deadline is shorter than a general child injury claim and is subject to a hard 10-year cap that ordinary personal injury cases do not face.
| Category of Defendant | Statute of Limitations | Infancy Toll | Effective Deadline | Primary Statute |
| Private hospital / private physician | 2.5 years | Yes — but capped at 10 years from malpractice | Child's 10th birthday in most cases | CPLR §214-a + CPLR §208 |
| Public hospital (NYC Health + Hospitals, SUNY Upstate, SUNY Downstate, Stony Brook, county hospitals) | 1 year and 90 days after Notice of Claim | No — 90-day Notice of Claim NOT tolled by infancy | 90 days from injury to file Notice of Claim | GML §50-e |
| Wrongful death of infant | 2 years from date of death | N/A | 2 years from death | EPTL §5-4.1 |
| Parents' derivative claim | 2.5 years | No — not tolled by child's infancy | 2.5 years from malpractice | CPLR §214-a |
ACT NOW BEFORE YOUR SHOULDER DYSTOCIA CLAIM DEADLINE EXPIRES →
Was Shoulder Dystocia Mismanaged During Delivery?
Let us help. Our clients don't have to pay anything unless we win.
1. Request the complete labor-and-delivery record, including the shoulder dystocia documentation. Under New York Public Health Law §18, you are entitled to your and your child's complete medical records within a reasonable time of a written request. Per ACOG Practice Bulletin No. 178, shoulder dystocia events should be contemporaneously documented — request the head-to-body interval, the maneuvers attempted in order, the personnel present, and any traction or pressure applied.
2. Request the nursing notes separately. Nursing notes often contain details that are absent from the physician's delivery summary — including the timing of maneuvers, who called for help, and what pressure was applied.
3. Document every pediatric and therapy visit. Keep a dated log of physical therapy, occupational therapy, and every specialist appointment with pediatric neurology, pediatric orthopedics, or hand surgery. The child's recovery trajectory over the first year is central to both the prognosis and the damages calculation.
4. Photograph the affected arm regularly. If the injury involves the brachial plexus, resting position, range of motion, and limb-length comparisons over time are critical evidence. Begin photographing shortly after birth and continue monthly.
5. Act quickly if your child was born at a public hospital. Births at NYC Health + Hospitals facilities, SUNY Upstate, SUNY Downstate, Stony Brook, or any county-run facility require a Notice of Claim within 90 days under GML §50-e. Missing this deadline can bar the claim entirely.
6. Contact a New York shoulder dystocia injury attorney. Porter Law Group offers free consultations on a contingency-fee basis and handles every stage of the case, from record collection through expert review, litigation, infant compromise approval, and trial.
GET A FREE CASE REVIEW: CALL (833) PORTER-9 →
Porter Law Group represents families in shoulder dystocia and related birth injury malpractice cases throughout New York State, with a statewide practice reaching every county and jurisdiction. Our Syracuse headquarters serves Central and Upstate New York, while attorneys travel regularly to downstate courthouses for cases in the five boroughs, Westchester, and Long Island.
Serving Clients statewide, including Shoulder Dystocia Injury Attorney in Syracuse, New York City, Manhattan, Buffalo, Rochester, Albany, Yonkers, White Plains, Utica, Binghamton, Long Island (Nassau and Suffolk Counties), Saratoga Springs, Ithaca.
Wherever your child was injured in New York, call (833) PORTER-9 for a free consultation with an experienced birth injury attorney.
No. ACOG Practice Bulletin No. 178 (May 2017) explicitly classifies shoulder dystocia as an "unpredictable and unpreventable obstetric emergency," and ACOG further notes that the pre-pregnancy, antepartum, and intrapartum risk factors have "extremely poor predictive value." This means the emergency itself is generally not malpractice. The malpractice analysis turns on the response: did the team announce the dystocia, call for help, track elapsed time, and perform the McRoberts-first sequence — or did the team apply excessive lateral traction, use fundal pressure, or skip the recognized maneuvers? When the chart documents the latter and the resulting injury is consistent with that response, the case for malpractice is generally strong.
The McRoberts maneuver involves sharply flexing the mother's legs against her abdomen, which rotates the symphysis pubis cephalad and opens the pelvic outlet. Per the 2024 NIH StatPearls review, the McRoberts maneuver alone resolves up to 42% of shoulder dystocia. ACOG, the Royal College of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists, and the Advanced Life Support in Obstetrics program all recommend it as the first maneuver in the management sequence. Failure to attempt McRoberts before resorting to traction or other maneuvers is a recognized deviation from the standard of care, and the chart's documentation of which maneuvers were performed in what order is often the central evidence in shoulder dystocia litigation.
Suprapubic pressure and fundal pressure are fundamentally different and have opposite implications for shoulder dystocia. Suprapubic pressure is applied just above the mother's pubic bone and is intended to push the impacted anterior shoulder downward and into a more favorable diameter; ACOG endorses suprapubic pressure as an early management step, performed concurrently with the McRoberts maneuver. Fundal pressure is applied to the top of the uterus and is intended to push the fetus downward; fundal pressure is contraindicated in shoulder dystocia because it does not disimpact the shoulder and has been linked to brachial plexus injuries and skeletal fractures. When the chart documents fundal pressure during a shoulder dystocia, it is a recognized deviation from the published standard of care.
Shoulder dystocia can cause both fetal and maternal injuries. The most common fetal injuries are brachial plexus injuries (including Erb's palsy and Klumpke palsy), clavicle fractures, and humerus fractures. In severe cases with prolonged head-to-body delivery interval, hypoxic-ischemic encephalopathy can develop because of cord compression — leading to permanent brain injury and cerebral palsy. Cervical spinal cord injuries are rarer but can result from hyperextension during dystocia management. Maternal injuries include third- and fourth-degree perineal lacerations, postpartum hemorrhage, symphyseal separation, and transient femoral neuropathy — particularly when the McRoberts maneuver is held for extended periods.
Possibly. Per ACOG Practice Bulletin No. 178 and consistent obstetric guidance, planned cesarean delivery may be considered and discussed with the patient when fetal weight is estimated above 4,500 g (approximately 9 lbs 15 oz) in a mother without diabetes, or above 4,000 g (approximately 8 lbs 13 oz) in a mother with pre-pregnancy or gestational diabetes. The 2024 NIH StatPearls review confirms shoulder dystocia incidence rises sharply with birth weight, approximately 1% for infants under 4,000 g, 5% for infants 4,000–4,500 g, and 9–10% for infants over 4,500 g. A prior history of shoulder dystocia is itself a recognized indication for the cesarean discussion regardless of estimated fetal weight, and the recommendation is even stronger when the prior dystocia involved permanent neonatal injury. Failure to engage in this discussion when these factors are present is a recognized basis for malpractice.
Shoulder dystocia injury claims are medical malpractice actions under CPLR §214-a, which imposes a 2.5-year statute of limitations. CPLR §208 tolls the deadline during the child's minority, but caps the toll at 10 years from the malpractice, meaning most shoulder dystocia cases must be filed before the child's 10th birthday. Deliveries at public hospitals (NYC Health + Hospitals, SUNY Upstate, SUNY Downstate) require a Notice of Claim within 90 days of the injury under General Municipal Law §50-e, and the infancy toll does not extend the 90-day deadline. Parents' separate derivative claims follow their own 2.5-year statute and are not tolled by the child's infancy.
Shoulder dystocia settlements vary widely based on the severity and permanence of the resulting injury. Mild brachial plexus injuries with full recovery resolve at modest values, while permanent brachial plexus injuries routinely settle in the seven-figure range, and catastrophic cases involving HIE-to-cerebral-palsy can reach eight figures. The CDC estimates the lifetime cost of care for an individual with cerebral palsy at approximately $1 million in 2003 dollars, with medical costs running roughly 10 times higher than for children without CP. New York places no statutory cap on damages in medical malpractice cases. Every settlement of a minor's claim must be approved by a judge at an infant compromise hearing under CPLR §1207, and attorney fees follow the sliding scale in Judiciary Law §474-a: 30% of the first $250,000, 25% of the next $250,000, 20% of the next $500,000, 15% of the next $250,000, and 10% of any amount over $1,250,000.
Under-documentation of shoulder dystocia is itself a deviation from the published standard of care. ACOG explicitly recommends contemporaneous documentation of every shoulder dystocia event, including the head-to-body interval, every maneuver performed, the order of maneuvers, and the personnel involved. When the obstetric record is silent on shoulder dystocia but the infant has injuries consistent with a difficult delivery, clavicle or humerus fracture, brachial plexus injury, cephalohematoma, or unexplained hypoxic injury — under-documentation often becomes its own basis for malpractice analysis. Independent records (fetal heart monitoring strips, nursing notes, neonatal exam, photographs) and the 2014 ACOG Task Force on Neonatal Brachial Plexus Palsy finding that brachial plexus palsy can occur "without clinically recognizable shoulder dystocia" mean the absence of charted dystocia does not foreclose a malpractice claim.
Michael S. Porter is the founder and managing partner of Porter Law Group, representing New York families in birth injury, brachial plexus, medical malpractice, and catastrophic injury cases. A graduate of Harvard University (B.A., 1994) and Syracuse University College of Law (J.D., 1997), Porter served four years as a Captain in the U.S. Army Judge Advocate General's Corps. Selected to Super Lawyers for 14 consecutive years (2012–2025), he holds a 10.0 Superb rating on Avvo and a Distinguished rating from Martindale-Hubbell.
Bar Admissions: New York State Bar | U.S. District Court, Northern and Western Districts of New York
Memberships: New York State Bar Association, Onondaga County Bar Association, New York State Academy of Trial Lawyers, Multi-Million Dollar Advocates Forum
If your child suffered a shoulder dystocia injury during a New York delivery, critical deadlines may run faster than you expect: public-hospital cases require a Notice of Claim within 90 days, parents' derivative claims are not tolled by the child's infancy, and the 10-year cap under CPLR §208 closes most birth injury windows before a child's 10th birthday.
Contact Porter Law Group today at (833) PORTER-9 for a free, no-obligation consultation. We operate on a contingency-fee basis, so you pay nothing unless you win.
Phone: +1 833-767-8379
Email: info@porterlawteam.com
Monday to Friday: 8 AM to 5 PM | Saturday and Sunday: Closed
Avoid sharing confidential information via contact form, text, or voicemail as they are not secure. Please be aware that using any of these communication methods does not establish an attorney-client relationship. *By appointment only.
The information contained on this site is proprietary and protected. Any unauthorized or illegal use, copying, or dissemination will be prosecuted to the fullest extent of the law. All content on this site is provided for informational purposes only. It is not, nor should it be taken as medical or legal advice. None of the content on this site is intended to substitute for medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment. Attorney Advertising.
We serve clients in every city and county in New York State. These include places like: The Adirondacks, Albany, Alexandria Bay, Amsterdam, Astoria, Auburn, Ballston Spa, Batavia, Beacon, Binghamton, Brooklyn, Buffalo, Canandaigua, Carthage, Cattaraugus, Catskill, Cayuga Lake, Cazenovia, Chelsea, Clayton, Clifton Park, Cobleskill, Colonie, Cooperstown, Corning, Cortland, Delhi, Delmar, Dunkirk, East Aurora, East Hampton, Elmira, Fayetteville, Finger Lakes, Flushing, Fredonia, Fulton, Garden City, Geneva, Glen Cove, Glens Falls, Gloversville, Gouverneur, Great Neck, Greenwich Village, Hamilton, Hammondsport, Harlem, Haverstraw, Hempstead, Herkimer, Hornell, Hudson, Huntington, Ilion, Ithaca, Jamaica, Jamestown, Johnstown, Kingston, Lake George, Lake Placid, Lewiston, Little Falls, Liverpool, Lockport, Long Island City, Lowville, Malone, Manhattan, Manlius, Massena, Medina, Middletown, Monticello, Montauk, Mount Vernon, New Paltz, New Rochelle, Newburgh, Niagara Falls, North Tonawanda, Norwich, Nyack, Ogdensburg, Old Forge, Olean, Oneida, Oneonta, Ossining, Oswego, Penn Yan, Peekskill, Plattsburgh, Port Chester, Potsdam, Poughkeepsie, Queens, Rhinebeck, Riverhead, Rochester, Rome, Rye, Sag Harbor, Saranac Lake, Saratoga Springs, Schenectady, Seneca Falls, Seneca Lake, Skaneateles, SoHo, Southampton, Spring Valley, Staten Island, Stony Brook, Suffern, Syracuse, Tarrytown, The Bronx, Thousand Islands, Ticonderoga, Troy, Tupper Lake, Utica, Warsaw, Waterloo, Watertown, Watkins Glen, Wellsville, White Plains, Williamsburg, Woodstock, Yonkers, and many more communities throughout New York State.
Copyright © 2026, Porter Law Group. Personal Injury Lawyers
Made with 💛 by Gold Penguin
