$1.7 Million Settlement Demanded in Medical Malpractice Case Involving Failed Knee Surgery

The Porter Law Group is representing a significant medical malpractice case involving a catastrophically failed knee surgery that left a previously active patient permanently disabled. The case centers on multiple allegations of negligence during an anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) reconstruction surgery performed in 2015, which ultimately led to the need for a total knee replacement in a patient only 41 years old.

Are You Seeking Compensation for Medical Malpractice?

Reach out to our team to know your legal options (free and non-obligatory).

Contact Us

The case began when the client sought treatment for right knee pain following a workplace incident. Despite MRI results showing only a possible ACL strain without definitive tear, the treating physician recommended and proceeded with ACL reconstruction surgery using cadaver tissue. This decision would prove to have devastating consequences for the client's future mobility and quality of life.

The legal investigation revealed three primary areas of alleged malpractice. First, the ACL surgery itself was deemed unnecessary and contraindicated based on the client's symptoms and diagnostic imaging. The client's initial presentation was inconsistent with typical ACL injury patterns, which usually manifest with medial knee pain and joint instability - symptoms that were notably absent in this case.

Second, the surgical procedure itself was reportedly performed in a grossly negligent manner. Medical experts retained by the Porter Law Group identified critical errors in the placement of the Biomet EZLoc metallic femoral fixation device. Instead of proper placement within the femoral bone, post-operative radiographs revealed the device was positioned intra-articularly - a serious technical error known to cause joint damage and lead to surgical failure.

Third, the investigation uncovered significant issues with informed consent. The client was allegedly never fully informed about all aspects of the surgical procedure, including the placement of a chondral fix implant, nor advised about the elevated risk of failure associated with the aggressive surgical approach chosen.

The consequences of these alleged failures have been severe and life-altering. Following the failed ACL reconstruction, the client experienced rapid and atypical arthritic progression, ultimately requiring a total knee replacement at an unusually young age. Medical experts project that the client will require at least two additional knee replacements over their lifetime due to the limited lifespan of knee prosthetics.

The economic impact has been substantial. The client, previously employed as a Certified Nursing Assistant, has been unable to return to work since the surgery. Worker's compensation evaluations have assessed a 50% loss of use of the right lower extremity. Economic losses, including past and future lost wages, loss of household services, and future medical expenses, are calculated to exceed $1 million.

Beyond the financial implications, the impact on the client's quality of life has been profound. Previously an active individual who enjoyed motorcycling, hiking, baseball, and swimming, the client now faces severe limitations in physical activities and requires ongoing pain management. The chronic pain has also led to sleep deprivation and other quality-of-life issues.

The legal team has identified significant insurance coverage available through the involved medical providers, including at least $2.3 million in coverage for the primary surgeon and additional coverage for other defendants. A settlement demand of $1.7 million has been issued, reflecting the severity of the malpractice and its life-long impact on the client.

This case underscores the devastating consequences that can result from medical negligence and the importance of thorough pre-operative evaluation and proper surgical technique. The Porter Law Group continues to advocate for patients who have suffered from medical malpractice, working to secure the compensation needed for ongoing care and life adjustments following such devastating injuries.

If you or a loved one has experienced complications from knee surgery or other medical procedures, it's crucial to seek experienced legal representation. Contact the Porter Law Group for a confidential consultation to discuss your rights and options.