In New York, dog bite laws combine the "one-bite rule," which gives a dog one chance before its owner can be held liable, with strict liability aspects, making owners responsible for any harm their dog causes under certain conditions.
Bit By A Dog In New York?
Schedule a consultation with us to learn how we could help
Understanding New York's Mixed Dog Bite Statute
Traditionally, the one-bite rule implies that a dog gets 'one free bite' before its owner can be held liable. This means that the owner may not be held responsible for a dog's first biting incident, provided they had no reason to believe the dog was dangerous.
In contrast, strict liability means that the dog owner is responsible for a bite, regardless of the dog's past behavior. New York's statute incorporates limited strict liability, particularly in cases where the dog bite causes medical or veterinary costs. This means that even if it's the first incident, the owner might still bear some financial responsibility.
If you or a loved one was bitten by a dog in New York, you should reach out to an experienced dog bite attorney. For guidance on New York State's dog bite accidents and dedicated legal representation, contact us at 833-PORTER9 or email info@porterlawteam.com for a free consultation.
Definition of a "Dangerous Dog" in New York
In New York State, the legal definition of a "dangerous dog" is quite specific and detailed. According to NY Agric. & Mkts. Law § 108(24):
- Unjustified Attacks: A dog is considered dangerous if it attacks a person, companion animal, farm animal, or domestic animal without justification, causing physical injury or death.
- Threatening Behavior: A dog may also be classified as dangerous if it behaves in a way that a reasonable person would perceive as posing a serious and unjustified imminent threat of serious physical injury or death to people or animals.
- Attacks on Service Animals: Additionally, a dog that attacks a service dog, guide dog, or hearing dog without justification and causes physical injury or death is deemed dangerous.
The Impact of Dog Bite Injuries
Dog bites are not only traumatic but can also lead to significant health hazards and high healthcare costs. If a dog bite results in a hospital visit, treatment, or even surgery, the medical expenses can grow rapidly. This is especially true in cases where ongoing care or rehabilitation is required.
Possible Dog Bite Injuries
While some dog bite injuries might appear minor, such as scratches and bruises, the potential for more severe consequences is real. Victims may suffer from:
- Deadly Infections: Such as rabies, which require immediate medical attention.
- Nerve Damage: This leads to loss of sensation or function in the affected area.
- Torn Ligaments: This can result in prolonged pain and mobility issues.
- Emotional Trauma and PTSD: The psychological impact of a dog bite can be long-lasting.
- Amputation: In severe cases, bites can lead to the loss of a limb.
- Fractured Bones: Especially in attacks by larger or more powerful dogs.
- Head Trauma: Particularly concerning in attacks on children or the elderly.
Legal Definitions and Implications on Dog Bite Cases
In the context of dog bite laws, an "owner" is not just the person who legally purchased or adopted the dog. It can also include anyone who keeps or harbors the dog, has it in their care, or allows it to remain on premises owned or controlled by them.
"Harboring" refers to the act of sheltering or giving refuge to a dog. It does not require formal ownership or a long-term arrangement. Even temporary care or control can qualify someone as harboring the dog.
These definitions broaden the scope of who can be held liable in a dog bite case. It's not limited to the registered owner; anyone responsible for the dog at the time of the incident could potentially face legal consequences.
Evidence of Vicious Propensity
In legal proceedings, establishing a dog's vicious propensity is critical. Various types of evidence can be considered:
- Prior Incidents: Evidence of previous bites or attacks is a strong indicator of vicious propensity. This includes any documented history of aggression.
- Behavioral Signs: Signs of aggressive behavior, such as growling, snarling, or baring teeth, can be considered. Even if these behaviors did not result in an injury, they can be relevant.
- Witness Testimony: Statements from neighbors or others who have observed the dog's behavior can be influential.
- Owner's Admissions: Any statements or admissions by the owner acknowledging the dog's aggressive tendencies can be used as evidence.
The owner's awareness of their dog's vicious propensity is important. If it can be proven that the owner knew or should have known about the dog's aggressive nature, it impacts liability and potential legal outcomes.
Exceptions and Special Circumstances
Not all situations lead to owner liability. For instance, police dogs performing their duties are generally exempt from these laws. Additionally, if a dog bites in self-defense or while defending its owner, this may also be considered an exception.
Landlords can sometimes be held liable for dog bites that occur on their property. This is particularly the case if the landlord knew of the dog's presence and its vicious propensity and had control over the premises where the bite occurred.
Negligence and Dog Bites
Negligence refers to the failure to take reasonable care to prevent harm. In dog bite cases, if an owner's negligence led to the bite, they could be held liable. This could include situations where the dog was not properly restrained or was left unsupervised in an area accessible to the public.
It's important to distinguish between negligence and strict liability. While strict liability for medical costs applies in cases involving a "dangerous dog," negligence applies more broadly. An owner can be negligent even if the dog has no prior history of aggression.
Legal Remedies and Compensation for Dog Bites Victim
Victims of dog bites in New York State have several legal remedies and can seek various types of compensation.
Types of Damages Recoverable
- Present and future medical bills
- Pain and suffering
- Lost wages
- Lost earning potential
- Emotional distress
- Loss of companionship
- Loss of life enjoyment
- Rehabilitation costs
The process typically involves filing a claim against the dog owner's homeowner's insurance policy. It may require providing medical records, evidence of lost wages, and documentation of the incident. Legal action may be necessary if a settlement cannot be reached.
In ensuring a fair outcome in dog bite cases, legal representation plays an essential role. A knowledgeable personal injury attorney can help in gathering evidence, understanding the legal implications, and representing the interests of the client, whether they are the victim or the dog owner.
Criminal Penalties and Owner Responsibility
Owners of dogs deemed dangerous in New York State may face significant civil and criminal consequences if their dog causes injury or property damage. The consequences include:
- Financial Penalties: Owners might be required to pay two to three times the actual damages caused by the dog.
- Fines: Judges can impose fines for violations of dangerous dog restrictions.
- Jail Time: In severe cases, especially where serious injury occurs, owners may face imprisonment.
Additionally, in extreme cases, a judge may order the dog to be put down if it's found to be dangerous, particularly if the dog has caused serious injury or under other specific circumstances. While not always mandatory, this measure is undoubtedly considered in severe incidents.
Seek Expert Legal Support for Dog Bite Cases
If you or your loved one has been impacted by a dog bite incident, understanding your legal rights and options is crucial. At the Porter Law Group, we specialize in providing comprehensive legal support for dog bite cases.
We work on a contingency basis, so there are no fees unless you win. Our commitment is to protect your rights and secure fair compensation for your injuries.
For guidance on New York State's dog bite accidents and dedicated legal representation, if you or a loved one was in an accident, contact us at 833-PORTER9 or email info@porterlawteam.com to see how we could help.
