If you've been injured on someone else's property in New York, one of your first questions is likely: "What is my case worth?" While every premises liability case is unique, understanding common settlement ranges and the factors that influence compensation can help you set realistic expectations and make informed decisions about your legal options.
Injured On Someone Else's Property In New York?
CONTACT USOur Recent Case Results
Settlement
Jury Verdict
Settlement
Settlement
In reality, New York premises liability settlements vary widely from $10,000 for minor injuries to over $2 million for catastrophic harm.
At the Porter Law Group, we've secured substantial settlements and verdicts for injured clients throughout New York State, in all types of complex personal injury cases. We understand that behind every settlement figure is a person whose life has been changed by someone else's negligence, and we're committed to fighting for the compensation you truly deserve. If you've been injured on someone's property, contact us at 833-PORTER9 or email info@porterlawteam.com for a free consultation to discuss what your case might be worth.
Understanding New York Settlement Statistics
According to the NYC Comptroller's Office, the average personal injury settlement and judgment in fiscal year 2023 was $134,656, with 13,227 claims resolved for a total of $1.45 billion. However, this average includes everything from minor slips to catastrophic injuries—so it can be misleading. Averages usually don't tell the whole story when settlement amounts vary so dramatically.
More telling are the typical ranges we see in premises liability cases:
- Median settlement values for common injuries (e.g., knee or wrist): $75,000
- Top 25% of premises liability verdicts: $196,645 to $1.46 million
- Highest settlements and verdicts: Over $2.3 million in extreme cases
The Wide Range of Settlement Values
New York premises liability settlements usually fall into three categories:
Minor Injuries ($10,000 - $50,000):
- Sprains and strains requiring minimal treatment
- Minor fractures that heal completely
- Soft tissue injuries with full recovery
- Cases with short treatment periods and no lasting effects
Moderate Injuries ($75,000 - $500,000):
- Complex fractures requiring surgery
- Injuries requiring extensive physical therapy
- Cases with some permanent limitations or scarring
- Lost wages from extended time off work
Severe/Catastrophic Injuries ($500,000 - $2.3 million+):
- Traumatic brain injuries with lasting cognitive effects
- Spinal cord injuries resulting in paralysis
- Severe burns or disfigurement
- Injuries requiring lifetime medical care
Real-World Settlement Examples
High-Value Cases That Made Headlines
- $2.3 Million Spinal Cord Injury Settlement: A resident suffered paralysis due to negligent security in a residential building, resulting in a substantial settlement that covered lifetime medical care and adaptive equipment.
- $445,000 ACL Tear in Brooklyn: A customer slipped on an unmarked wet floor at a commercial establishment, tearing their ACL and requiring multiple surgeries and extended rehabilitation.
- $171.52 Million Record-Setting Award: While an extreme outlier, this record-setting payout for NYC's failure to release a pretrial detainee demonstrates that in cases of egregious government negligence, settlements can reach unprecedented levels.
More Typical Settlement Ranges
Most premises liability cases fall into more modest ranges, but still provide meaningful compensation:
- $85,000 Grocery Store Slip and Fall: A customer broke their wrist when they slipped on grapes that had been on the floor for over an hour, requiring surgery and physical therapy.
- $125,000 Apartment Building Stair Collapse: A visitor suffered multiple fractures when poorly maintained stairs gave way, resulting in permanent hardware implants and ongoing pain.
- $275,000 Restaurant Kitchen Injury: A delivery driver suffered severe burns from inadequately marked hot surfaces, requiring skin grafts and causing permanent scarring.
Critical Factors That Determine Settlement Value
Injury Severity and Medical Costs
The extent of your injuries is the most significant factor in determining settlement value. This includes both economic and non-economic damages:
Economic Damages:
- Acute fractures: $7,500 to $250,000+ in treatment costs depending on complexity
- Spinal cord injuries: $1 to $5 million for lifetime care, adaptive equipment, and home modifications
- Traumatic brain injuries: $500,000 to $2 million+ for ongoing rehabilitation and care
Non-Economic Damages: Pain and suffering awards often exceed medical costs by 2 to 5 times in severe cases. A $100,000 medical bill might result in $300,000 to $500,000 in total compensation when pain and suffering are included.
Liability Strength and Evidence Quality
The strength of your liability case dramatically affects settlement value:
Clear Liability Cases: When fault is obvious and well-documented, settlements tend to increase because insurance companies know they'll likely lose at trial.
Disputed Liability Cases: When fault is questionable, settlements may be reduced by 30-50% or more, regardless of injury severity.
Strong Evidence Factors:
- Surveillance footage of the accident
- Multiple witnesses to the dangerous condition
- Documented complaints about the hazard
- Clear building code violations
- Expert testimony supporting your version of events
The Impact of Comparative Negligence
New York's pure comparative fault system means your compensation is reduced by your percentage of fault.
Example: In a $500,000 case where you’re 30% at fault, you’d receive $350,000.
Common Comparative Fault Arguments:
- Distracted walking (cell phone use)
- Ignoring obvious hazards
- Inappropriate footwear for conditions
- Failure to use available handrails
Property Type and Defendant's Resources
The type of property and defendant significantly affects settlement values:
- Commercial Properties: Generally result in higher settlements due to stricter safety standards and higher insurance limits. National averages show commercial premises liability verdicts average $643,099.
- Municipal Claims: Subject to special rules including 90-day notice requirements, but NYC has substantial resources with annual tort payouts capped at $1.04 billion.
- Private Residences: Often have lower insurance limits, potentially capping available compensation.
- Large Corporations: Companies like major retailers or restaurant chains typically have higher insurance limits and may settle more readily to avoid negative publicity.
Jurisdictional Trends Affecting Settlements
The Rise of Nuclear Verdicts
In 2023, New York saw $2.004 billion in state court verdicts, with 42% involving workplace or premises liability cases. This trend toward "nuclear verdicts" affects settlement negotiations because:
- Insurance Companies Are More Cautious: Knowing that juries are awarding larger amounts, insurers may settle for higher amounts to avoid trial risk.
- Plaintiff Attorneys Have More Leverage: The possibility of extremely large verdicts gives skilled attorneys more negotiating power.
- Anchoring Effects: Attorneys can reference multi-million dollar awards during settlement discussions, influencing expectations.
The Impact of New York’s Scaffold Law
New York's Scaffold Law creates absolute liability for elevation-related construction injuries, leading to some of the highest premises liability settlements in the nation. This affects the overall settlement landscape by:
- Setting precedent for large awards in construction cases
- Shaping jury expectations in other premises liability cases
- Highlighting the value of strong liability laws
Municipal Liability Pressures
Government entities in New York face increasing pressure from large settlements:
NYPD Claims: $309.51 million paid in fiscal year 2024, representing a 31% year-over-year (YoY) increase.
Sidewalk Defects: Average settlement of $126,273 for Department of Sanitation claims related to sidewalk maintenance failures.
These large municipal payouts create budget pressures that sometimes lead to more aggressive settlement negotiations.
Timeline for Resolution
Simple Cases: Minor injuries with clear liability may settle within 6-12 months.
Complex Cases: Severe injuries or disputed liability can take 2-4 years to resolve.
Trial Cases: If settlement negotiations fail, trials can add another 1-2 years to the process.
Why Professional Representation Matters
Experienced premises liability attorneys typically secure settlements 40-60% higher than those achieved by unrepresented claimants or inexperienced lawyers. Insurers know which attorneys will go to trial and which will settle cheaply. If you are represented by inexperienced counsel, you may not be getting the best deal possible. At the Porter Law Group, we take pride in thorough investigation and securing expert testimony to ensure that you walk away with the best deal possible. We have dealt with insurance companies for decades, and we are well versed not only in the intricacies of litigation but also in the various insurance company tactics and settlement practices.
Our experienced premises liability attorneys at the Porter Law Group know the ins and outs of personal injury litigation throughout New York State. We have achieved some of the biggest settlements and awards for victims of negligence, and should you choose to work with us, you can be assured that we will put our time, expertise, and resources towards ensuring that you and your loved ones receive the best compensation possible for all your injuries and losses.
Were You Injured Because Of A Property Owner's Negligence?
Reach out to our experienced team for a free consultation.
Why Choose the Porter Law Group
The lawyers at the Porter Law Group have decades of experience representing individuals and families whose lives have been devastated by catastrophic injuries. We have obtained some of the largest settlements and verdicts in courts throughout the State of New York. We are a state-wide firm that handles cases with a hometown feel.
Our clients come to us looking for guidance and answers. With seasoned trial lawyers, the Porter Law Group has the resources necessary to help you navigate the most complex cases, against goliath insurance companies that will stop at nothing to prevent you from receiving the compensation you deserve.
You only get one chance to hire the best lawyer for you and your family. Hire the lawyers most recommended by former clients and local attorneys, and the firm that obtains superior results.
When you or a loved one’s life has been devastated by a serious personal injury in New York, don’t hire a lawyer without calling the Porter Law Group to learn why so many of our clients are thankful they trusted us with their case in their time of need.
Contact an Experienced Premises Liability Lawyer Today
While average settlement figures provide helpful context, your case's value depends on its unique circumstances. A minor injury with clear liability might settle for more than a severe injury with questionable fault. The key is building the strongest possible case through immediate action, comprehensive documentation, and skilled legal representation.
Don't let insurance companies convince you to accept less than you deserve by citing "average" settlements. Every case is different, and with proper preparation and aggressive advocacy, your settlement can exceed any average.
If you've been injured on someone else's property in New York, the time to act is now. Evidence disappears, witnesses forget, and procedural deadlines approach quickly. Contact the Porter Law Group today at 833-PORTER9 or email info@porterlawteam.com for a free consultation to discuss what your case might be worth.
Remember: we work on a contingency fee basis, meaning you pay no attorney fees unless we successfully recover compensation for you. Don't let concerns about legal costs prevent you from seeking the justice and compensation you deserve.
Your injuries are real, your damages are significant, and you deserve compensation that reflects the true impact of your accident on your life. Let the Porter Law Group fight for the maximum settlement possible in your premises liability case.
