Yes, you can fire your personal injury lawyer at any time and for any reason. New York's Rules of Professional Conduct are clear on this point. Rule 1.16, codified at 22 NYCRR § 1200.1.16, lists the circumstances under which an attorney must or may withdraw from a case.
Beyond the rule itself, the New York Courts publish a Statement of Client Rights that reinforces what you are entitled to throughout the attorney-client relationship.
That includes the right to your lawyer's undivided loyalty, the right to be kept informed about your case, the right to reasonable communication, and the right to a written fee agreement in most matters.
If those rights have been consistently violated, that is not just a personal grievance. It is a legitimate and well-recognized reason to change counsel.
Talk to a New York Personal Injury Lawyer Today
CONTACT USOur Recent Case Results
Settlement
Jury Verdict
Settlement
Settlement
How to Actually Fire Your Personal Injury Lawyer
Changing lawyers is not a dramatic event. It is a legal and administrative process, and doing it in the right order protects you.
1. Find your new lawyer first.
Do not fire your current attorney before you have a replacement lined up. If there are active court deadlines, a pending statute of limitations, or a deposition scheduled, going even a short period without representation creates real risk. Most new personal injury attorneys will help manage the transition once you retain them, including handling the formal substitution of counsel.
2. Review your retainer agreement.
Check whether your contract specifies any procedure for termination. Look at how advance fees or costs are handled, and whether any portion is labeled as nonrefundable. This affects how any fee dispute gets resolved later.
3. Send a written termination notice.
Put the discharge in writing and send it by certified mail. The letter does not need to be complicated. It should state clearly that you are ending the attorney-client relationship, request your complete case file, and direct that the file be sent either to you or to your new attorney with their contact information included.
4. File a substitution of counsel if there is an active lawsuit.
When a case is already in court, attorneys cannot simply stop appearing without judicial approval. In New York, this is typically handled through a Consent to Change Attorney form filed with the court. Your new lawyer will prepare and file this. Courts routinely approve substitutions as long as the timing does not prejudice the opposing party or unreasonably delay the case.
5. Clarify how prior fees will be handled before signing a new retainer.
Your new attorney needs to acknowledge that prior counsel may assert a lien, and they should explain how that gets resolved from your eventual recovery. Get that understanding in writing.
Will You End Up Paying Two Lawyers?
Personal injury cases in New York are almost universally handled on a contingency fee basis, meaning the lawyers only get paid if you win or settle.
When you fire one contingency lawyer and hire another, the total contingency percentage you agreed to does not double. What happens instead is that the original fee gets divided between the two firms, based on each lawyer's contribution to the case.
That division is worked out between the attorneys, and if they cannot agree, a court can resolve the dispute.
Under New York Judiciary Law § 474-a, contingency fees in personal injury cases are also governed by a statutory sliding scale, which caps what attorneys can charge based on the amount recovered.
Your new lawyer cannot simply tack on a full additional contingency percentage on top of what the first lawyer was owed. For a full breakdown of how those percentages work across different case types, see our guide on what percentage personal injury lawyers take in New York.
What Happens to Your Case File When You Fire Your Lawyer?
Your case file belongs to you. Under Rule 1.16(e) of the New York Rules of Professional Conduct, when representation ends, the attorney is required to give you reasonable notice, allow you time to hire new counsel, and deliver all papers and property you are entitled to.
The lawyer must also promptly refund any portion of a fee paid in advance that has not yet been earned.
Where things get complicated is with attorney's liens. New York recognizes two types:
| Lien Type | What It Covers | When It Applies |
| Charging Lien | Attaches to your eventual recovery (settlement or judgment) | When the lawyer has done work on a case that results in money |
| Retaining Lien | Allows the lawyer to hold your file until fee disputes are resolved | Subject to ethical limits; cannot be used to prejudice your case |
A retaining lien does not give a discharged lawyer unlimited leverage over your file. If holding the file would seriously harm your case, courts have discretion to order its release.
The practical reality is that most transitions between lawyers in personal injury cases happen with the new firm handling the mechanics, including file transfer and fee allocation, without the client getting caught in the middle.
When Does It Actually Make Sense to Fire Your Lawyer?
Not every frustration warrants a switch. Litigation moves slowly, and some of what feels like neglect is just the reality of how personal injury cases progress through the court system.
That said, there are situations where changing counsel is the right call.
The clearest signal is a pattern of no communication. Not a delayed return call, but weeks of silence, unreturned emails, and no updates on meaningful developments in your case.
The New York Statement of Client Rights specifically entitles you to be kept informed. A lawyer who routinely fails this baseline is not just annoying. They are violating their professional obligations.
Pressure to accept a settlement you do not believe is fair is another serious red flag, particularly when your lawyer cannot clearly explain the risks of holding out for more.
You have the right to make informed decisions about your own case. If your lawyer is pushing you toward a number without a real conversation about why, that is worth taking seriously.
What Are the Risks of Switching Lawyers Mid-Case?
Timing matters. Switching lawyers two weeks before trial, or within weeks of a statute of limitations expiring, introduces real risk.
A new attorney needs time to get up to speed, review the file, and potentially refile or respond to pending motions.
The general personal injury statute of limitations in New York is three years from the date of the accident under CPLR § 214. Medical malpractice cases carry a shorter deadline of 2.5 years under CPLR § 214-a. If you are close to either of those deadlines and your current representation is inadequate, the urgency is actually a reason to move faster, not to wait. The risk of inaction is often greater than the risk of switching.
If your case involves a claim against a city, county, or state entity, including wrongful death claims, there is an additional wrinkle: New York requires a Notice of Claim to be filed within 90 days of the incident, and this cannot be undone. If that deadline has already passed without a filing, that needs to be addressed with any new attorney immediately.
Switching lawyers is not inherently harmful to your case. In fact, when a client has been underserved, bringing in new counsel with fresh energy and proper resources often improves outcomes.
The key is making the change deliberately and without creating gaps in representation.
Thinking About Changing Personal Injury Lawyers in New York?
You have the right to switch attorneys if communication has broken down or trust is gone. Speak with a legal team about your options and next steps.
Summing It Up
Firing your personal injury lawyer in New York is a protected right under 22 NYCRR § 1200.1.16, and exercising that right does not mean you will pay double in fees or lose your case.
The process is manageable when done in the right order: find new counsel first, give written notice, and let your new lawyer handle the formal substitution and file transfer.
Attorney's liens exist, but they are resolved between the lawyers out of the eventual recovery, not as an additional charge to you.
If you are weighing whether your situation justifies a change, the honest test is this: do you trust your lawyer, and do you feel they are genuinely working your case? If the answer is no and the reasons are substantive, that is enough.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I fire my personal injury lawyer before my case settles?
Yes. You can discharge your lawyer at any point before, during, or even close to settlement, though switching attorneys very late in the process can complicate negotiations. Under New York Rule of Professional Conduct 1.16, a lawyer must withdraw once discharged. If settlement talks are already in progress, your new attorney will step in and handle the remainder of those negotiations. It is worth knowing that even after discharge, your former lawyer may be entitled to a portion of the final fee based on the work they contributed, which gets resolved between the two firms.
Will I have to pay my old lawyer even after I fire them?
Possibly, yes, but not as a separate bill on top of your new contingency fee. In contingency cases, the total fee percentage is typically divided between prior and current counsel based on each lawyer's contribution to the case. New York Judiciary Law § 474-a governs the fee schedule, and courts can resolve disputes if the attorneys cannot agree. You should not end up paying more than the originally agreed contingency percentage on your total recovery.
Can my lawyer refuse to give me my file after I fire them?
Not without limits. Under New York Rule 1.16(e), the discharged attorney is required to deliver all papers and property you are entitled to. A retaining lien does allow a lawyer to hold certain documents pending resolution of a fee dispute, but this right is not absolute. If withholding the file would seriously prejudice your case, a court can order its release. In practice, most file transfers in personal injury cases are handled by the incoming attorney directly.
Can I fire my lawyer and represent myself?
Legally, yes. As a party to your own case, you have the right to proceed pro se, meaning without a lawyer. That said, personal injury litigation in New York involves procedural rules, discovery obligations, expert witness requirements, and court deadlines that are genuinely difficult to manage without legal experience. For cases of any significant value, proceeding without a lawyer typically results in a lower recovery, if any. If your concern is the lawyer rather than legal representation itself, finding new counsel is almost always the better path. Our overview of why you need a personal injury attorney explains what proper representation actually involves and what to look for when evaluating a new firm.
Does firing my lawyer hurt my chances of winning?
Not inherently. A transition handled properly, with no gaps in representation and full file transfer, does not weaken your underlying claim.In cases where a client has been underrepresented or their case mismanaged particularly in complex matters like birth injury medical malpractice, bringing in new counsel can actually strengthen the case by correcting prior errors, conducting overdue discovery, or retaining better expert witnesses. The risk is in the transition itself, specifically in timing and making sure no deadlines fall through the cracks.
What if my lawyer withdraws from my case without my agreement?
A lawyer can also initiate withdrawal under Rule 1.16, but only in specific circumstances, such as a client's failure to pay fees, a fundamental breakdown in communication, or an irreconcilable conflict. In an active lawsuit, the attorney must obtain court permission before withdrawing and must take steps to protect your interests in the meantime, including giving reasonable notice and returning your file. If a lawyer withdraws in a way you believe has damaged your case, that itself may give rise to a separate legal complaint or ethics grievance.
Should I tell my current lawyer I'm looking for a new one?
You are not required to, and in most cases, it is not advisable to do so until you have already retained replacement counsel. There is no professional obligation on your part to warn your current lawyer that you are considering a change. Once you have secured a new attorney and signed a retainer, the formal discharge and substitution process will notify your current lawyer through proper channels.
What is a Consent to Change Attorney in New York?
A Consent to Change Attorney is a standard court form used in New York when a client switches legal representation in an active lawsuit. It is signed by the client, the outgoing attorney, and the incoming attorney, then filed with the court. Once approved, the new attorney takes over official responsibility for the case. If the outgoing attorney refuses to sign, the incoming attorney can file a motion with the court to compel the substitution, which courts routinely grant when the client has clearly discharged the prior lawyer.
