FMCSA violation-based truck accident claims in New York can produce settlements ranging from $250,000 to over $10 million because a documented federal safety violation creates per se evidence of negligence, meaning the violation itself proves the trucking company or driver breached the duty of care. The Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration (FMCSA) regulates every aspect of commercial trucking through 49 CFR Parts 390-399, covering driver qualifications, Hours of Service, vehicle maintenance, cargo securement, drug and alcohol testing, and hazardous materials transportation. When a crash results from a documented FMCSA violation, New York courts treat the violation as presumptive proof of negligence under CPLR §1411, shifting the burden to the carrier to explain why the violation did not cause the crash.
Settlement
Jury Verdict
Settlement
Settlement
HOS violation cases are won or lost on electronic data that must be preserved within days of the crash. Porter Law Group has recovered more than $500 million for injured clients since 2009, with published jury verdicts showing 20x to 34x multipliers over pre-trial offers. Led by Harvard-educated attorney Michael S. Porter, a former U.S. Army JAG Corps Captain with over 20 years of trial experience, the firm sends spoliation letters within 24 hours of engagement demanding preservation of the truck's Electronic Logging Device (ELD) data, dispatch records, and driver status logs. The firm's engineers overlay the ELD timeline with the event data recorder speed and braking data to reconstruct exactly what the driver was doing in the hours before the crash. Seven of eight attorneys are recognized by Super Lawyers, a distinction earned by fewer than 5% of New York attorneys.
"The ELD does not lie. It records every minute of driving time, every break, every status change. When the data shows the driver was in the 13th hour of driving after only 6 hours of rest, the HOS violation is indisputable. Then we look at why the driver was on the road that long. Was it the carrier's delivery schedule? Was it the dispatcher who called and said keep driving? That is where the punitive damages come from." Michael S. Porter, J.D., Porter Law Group
REQUEST A NO-OBLIGATION CASE REVIEW
The FMCSA's HOS regulations establish specific limits on driving time, on-duty time, and mandatory rest periods. Each rule addresses a different dimension of fatigue risk, and violations of any single rule create per se negligence.
| HOS Rule | Requirement | What Violation Looks Like |
| 11-Hour Driving Limit | Maximum 11 hours of driving after 10 consecutive hours off duty | ELD shows 12, 13, or 14+ hours of driving before the crash |
| 14-Hour Duty Window | All driving must occur within 14 hours of starting the duty period; cannot drive after the 14th hour even if driving time remains | Driver began duty at 5 AM, crash occurred at 8 PM (15th hour of duty) |
| 30-Minute Break | Must take a 30-minute break after 8 cumulative hours of driving | ELD shows 9+ hours of continuous driving without a break |
| 10-Hour Off-Duty | Must have 10 consecutive hours off duty before beginning a new driving period | Driver took only 7 hours off before starting the next shift |
| 60/70-Hour Weekly Limit | Cannot drive after 60 hours on duty in 7 days (or 70 hours in 8 days) | ELD shows 75 hours on duty over the past 8 days |
| 34-Hour Restart | A 34-hour off-duty period resets the 60/70-hour weekly clock | Driver claims a restart but ELD shows on-duty activity during the 34-hour window |
Each rule violation is independently actionable. A driver who violates both the 11-hour driving limit and the 10-hour off-duty requirement has committed two separate violations, each creating independent per se negligence.
Fatigue impairs driving ability as severely as alcohol. Research cited by the FMCSA shows that a driver who has been awake for 18 hours experiences cognitive impairment equivalent to a blood alcohol concentration of 0.05%, and 24 hours without sleep produces impairment equivalent to 0.10% BAC, above the legal limit for all drivers. A truck driver who has exceeded the 11-hour driving limit or who did not take the required 10-hour rest period is operating in this impairment zone. Learn more about truck driver fatigue.
Delayed reaction time causes rear-end and override crashes. A fatigued driver's reaction time slows by 15 to 30%, adding 75 to 150 feet of unbraked travel at 65 mph. This converts near-misses into full-speed rear-end collisions and override crashes that are catastrophic for the occupants of the smaller vehicle.
Microsleep episodes cause lane departure crashes. Microsleep is an involuntary sleep episode lasting 1 to 30 seconds that a fatigued driver cannot prevent. At 65 mph, a 4-second microsleep sends the truck 380 feet with no driver input. If the truck drifts across the center line, the result is a head-on collision. If the truck drifts off the road, the driver's overcorrection can cause a rollover or jackknife. Microsleep is undetectable on the truck's event data recorder, but the ELD data proving the driver was in the 13th or 14th hour of driving creates a strong inference that microsleep contributed to the crash.
Carrier dispatch pressure forces drivers to violate limits. Trucking companies that set delivery schedules requiring more than 11 hours of driving, that penalize drivers for taking required breaks, or that send dispatch messages pressuring drivers to 'keep rolling' are the root cause of most HOS violations. Learn more about trucking company negligence. Dispatch records, driver-dispatcher text messages, and delivery timelines that are mathematically impossible to meet within HOS limits prove the carrier created the conditions for the violation.
Electronic Logging Devices (ELDs) are the primary evidence. Since the FMCSA's ELD mandate took effect in December 2017, all regulated commercial trucks must use ELDs that automatically record driving time by connecting to the truck's engine. ELDs track driving status (driving, on-duty not driving, sleeper berth, off-duty), time in each status, and the transitions between statuses. This data is tamper-resistant and provides a minute-by-minute record of the driver's activity. Learn more about ELD and black box evidence.
Dispatch records prove carrier pressure. Electronic dispatch logs, delivery schedules, load assignments, and driver-dispatcher communications are all discoverable during litigation. When the delivery timeline shows the pickup was at 6 AM in Buffalo and the delivery was due at 8 PM in New York City (a trip requiring 6 to 7 hours of driving plus loading and unloading), the schedule is achievable within HOS limits. But when the same driver had a second load to pick up in New Jersey at 10 PM, the combined schedule required 14+ hours of driving. That math proves the carrier made the violation inevitable.
The FMCSA Safety Measurement System (SMS) proves a pattern. The SMS database publishes every carrier's HOS Compliance percentile score based on roadside inspection findings. A carrier with an elevated HOS Compliance score has a documented history of HOS violations across its fleet, proving the violation that caused your crash was not an isolated incident but a systemic business practice. This pattern evidence is essential for punitive damages.
The trucking company bears primary liability in most HOS violation cases. The FMCSA places the enforcement obligation on the carrier, not just the driver. Under 49 CFR §395.8, carriers must require drivers to record their duty status and must not permit or require drivers to exceed HOS limits. A carrier that knew (through real-time ELD monitoring) or should have known the driver was exceeding hours and did not intervene is directly negligent. Learn more about trucking company liability.
The truck driver bears individual liability for falsifying records. Drivers who manipulate ELD data, use a second device to split duty time, or claim sleeper berth time while actually driving bear personal liability for the falsification and for the resulting crash. However, when the driver falsified records because the carrier's schedule made compliance impossible, both parties are liable.
Third parties may share liability. Cargo shippers that imposed unrealistic delivery windows, brokers that assigned loads with impossible timelines, and loading facilities that delayed the driver for hours (reducing the available driving time) may all contribute to the HOS violation. Learn more about third-party liability.
New York's pure comparative negligence system (CPLR §1411) allows recovery from each at-fault party. HOS violation cases are among the strongest candidates for punitive damages because the carrier's knowing violation of federal fatigue prevention rules demonstrates conscious disregard for safety.
Economic damages cover medical expenses, lost wages, loss of earning capacity, and vehicle replacement. HOS violation crashes produce full-speed impacts because the fatigued driver does not brake before the collision. Traumatic brain injuries generate lifetime care costs exceeding $2 million. Spinal cord injuries range from $1.2 million to $5.1 million. Amputation injuries exceed $2 million in lifetime prosthetic and rehabilitation costs. Non-economic damages cover pain and suffering, emotional distress, disfigurement, and loss of enjoyment of life. New York places no cap on non-economic damages. Wrongful death claims under EPTL §5-4.1 typically settle between $1 million and $10 million. Punitive damages are especially strong in HOS cases because the ELD data proves the carrier knew (or had the technology to know in real time) that the driver was beyond legal hours and did nothing. New York does not cap punitive damages.
FIND OUT WHAT YOUR HOS VIOLATION CASE IS WORTH →
Porter Law Group's published results include 53 cases at or above $1 million, anchored by a $17.8 million settlement and a $13.5 million jury verdict.
$5,700,000 Settlement: 52-year-old man suffered a lower extremity amputation in a commercial trucking accident. Porter Law Group established liability through driver logbook violations, proving that the carrier's failure to enforce HOS rules directly caused the crash.
$3,400,000 Jury Verdict: 40-year-old man sustained a traumatic brain injury in a vehicle collision. The insurer offered $100,000. Porter Law Group secured $3.4 million, a 34x increase over the pre-trial offer.
Every case is different. Past results do not guarantee future outcomes.
Looking for Medical Compensation after a Dog Attack?
Let us help. Our clients don't have to pay anything unless we win.
Standard deadline: 3 years. Most HOS violation claims must be filed within 3 years under CPLR §214. However, ELD data is the most time-sensitive evidence in any HOS case. ELD records can be overwritten within 30 days if the carrier does not receive a preservation demand. Dispatch records and driver-dispatcher communications may be purged even faster.
Government entities: 90 days. If a government-operated truck was involved, a Notice of Claim must be filed within 90 days under General Municipal Law §50-e.
Wrongful death: 2 years. The estate has 2 years from the date of death under EPTL §5-4.1. Minors' claims are tolled until age 18.
ACT NOW BEFORE THE ELD DATA IS OVERWRITTEN →
1. Record the truck's DOT number, carrier name, and license plate. These identifiers allow your attorney to pull the carrier's SMS safety scores and HOS Compliance percentile within hours.
2. Note whether the driver appeared fatigued. Bloodshot eyes, slow speech, difficulty staying focused, yawning, and an inability to provide coherent answers are all observable signs of fatigue. Tell the responding officer if the driver appeared impaired by fatigue and request that the officer document it in the report.
3. Note the time and day of the crash. Crashes that occur between 2:00 AM and 6:00 AM or during the mid-afternoon (1:00 PM to 3:00 PM) are statistically correlated with fatigue. Crashes late in the work week (Thursday, Friday) may indicate cumulative fatigue from approaching the 60/70-hour weekly limit.
4. Seek medical attention within 24 hours. Full-speed fatigue crashes produce catastrophic injuries including traumatic brain injuries, spinal cord damage, and internal organ injuries with delayed symptoms.
5. Contact a truck accident lawyer immediately. An attorney can send a spoliation letter within 24 hours demanding preservation of the ELD data, dispatch records, driver logs, and the carrier's delivery schedule. This evidence can be overwritten within 30 days. Porter Law Group offers free consultations on a contingency-fee basis.
Porter Law Group represents truck accident victims pursuing Hours of Service violation claims throughout New York State. Headquartered in Syracuse with a statewide practice, the firm handles claims in every county and jurisdiction in New York, including Syracuse, New York City, Buffalo, Rochester, Albany, Yonkers, White Plains, Utica, Binghamton, and Long Island.
Call (833) PORTER-9 to speak with an experienced truck accident attorney who handles federal Hours of Service violation cases in your area.
A truck driver can drive a maximum of 11 hours after 10 consecutive hours off duty, and all driving must occur within a 14-hour on-duty window that begins when the driver starts any work activity. The driver must also take a 30-minute break after 8 cumulative hours of driving. These limits cannot be extended except under narrow emergency exemptions. The 14-hour window runs continuously and cannot be paused by off-duty breaks, meaning a driver who begins duty at 6 AM must stop driving by 8 PM regardless of how much driving time remains.
The truck's Electronic Logging Device (ELD) automatically records every minute of driving time, on-duty time, sleeper berth time, and off-duty time, creating a tamper-resistant digital record that proves whether the driver was within legal hours at the time of the crash. ELD data is the primary evidence. Dispatch records, delivery schedules, and driver-dispatcher communications corroborate the ELD data and prove whether the carrier's schedule made the violation inevitable. The carrier's SMS database HOS Compliance score proves a pattern of fleet-wide violations. Learn more about ELD and black box evidence.
Yes. The FMCSA places the enforcement obligation on the carrier, requiring companies to monitor driver hours through ELD data and to not permit or require drivers to exceed HOS limits. A carrier that had access to real-time ELD data showing the driver was beyond legal hours and did not intervene is directly negligent. A carrier whose delivery schedule made HOS compliance impossible created the conditions for the violation. Both forms of carrier negligence support punitive damages. Learn more about trucking company negligence.
An Electronic Logging Device (ELD) is a federally mandated device that connects to the truck's engine and automatically records driving time, replacing the handwritten paper logbooks that drivers previously used to track their hours. The ELD mandate, effective since December 2017, was implemented because paper logs were easily falsified. ELDs provide tamper-resistant, minute-by-minute records of the driver's duty status that prove whether HOS limits were observed. ELD data is the single most important piece of evidence in any HOS violation claim. Learn more about ELD and black box evidence.
While ELDs are designed to be tamper-resistant, drivers and carriers have been caught manipulating ELD data by disconnecting the device, using secondary devices, editing unassigned driving time, or claiming personal conveyance status while actually making commercial deliveries. Forensic analysis of ELD data can detect these manipulations by comparing the ELD record against GPS tracking data, fuel purchase receipts, toll records, and the event data recorder timestamps. Evidence of ELD tampering is powerful proof of the carrier's intent to violate HOS rules, which strongly supports punitive damages.
The 11-hour limit caps actual driving time, while the 14-hour window caps the total period during which driving is permitted, regardless of what the driver is doing. A driver who begins duty at 6 AM can drive until 8 PM (14-hour window) but can only accumulate 11 hours of actual driving during that window. Loading, unloading, paperwork, and waiting at docks count against the 14-hour window but not against the 11-hour driving limit. A driver who spends 4 hours loading has only 10 hours remaining in the duty window, even though the full 11 hours of driving time have not been used.
Yes. HOS violation cases are among the strongest candidates for punitive damages because the carrier's real-time ELD monitoring capability means the company knew or should have known the driver was beyond legal hours and chose not to intervene. Pattern evidence from the carrier's SMS HOS Compliance score proves the violations were systemic. A carrier with an elevated HOS percentile score that then has a fatigue-related crash has demonstrated the conscious disregard for safety that New York courts require for punitive awards. New York does not cap punitive damages.
The standard deadline is 3 years under CPLR §214, but ELD data can be overwritten within 30 days. A spoliation letter must be sent to the carrier within days of the crash demanding preservation of all ELD records, dispatch logs, and driver-dispatcher communications. Government entity claims require a 90-day Notice of Claim under General Municipal Law §50-e. Wrongful death claims carry a 2-year deadline under EPTL §5-4.1.
Porter Law Group works on a contingency-fee basis, meaning you pay nothing unless the firm recovers compensation for you. There are no upfront costs, retainers, or hourly fees. The firm covers all expenses for ELD data analysis, dispatch record discovery, SMS database research, fatigue experts, and litigation. If the case does not result in a recovery, you owe nothing.
Founder and managing partner of Porter Law Group. Harvard University (B.A., 1994), Syracuse University College of Law (J.D., 1997). Former U.S. Army JAG Corps Captain, Airborne Training School graduate. Super Lawyers 14 consecutive years, 10.0 Superb on Avvo, Distinguished rating from Martindale-Hubbell. Over 20 years of trial experience and $500 million in recoveries.
Reviewed by Michael S. Porter, J.D. | Last updated: [April, 2026]
Hours of Service violations prove the trucking company chose schedule pressure over federal fatigue prevention rules, and the ELD data that proves it can be overwritten within 30 days. Contact Porter Law Group at (833) PORTER-9 for a free, no-obligation consultation. We work on a contingency-fee basis, so you pay nothing unless you win.
Phone: +1 833-767-8379
Email: info@porterlawteam.com
Monday to Friday: 8 AM to 5 PM | Saturday and Sunday: Closed
Avoid sharing confidential information via contact form, text, or voicemail as they are not secure. Please be aware that using any of these communication methods does not establish an attorney-client relationship. *By appointment only.
The information contained on this site is proprietary and protected. Any unauthorized or illegal use, copying, or dissemination will be prosecuted to the fullest extent of the law. All content on this site is provided for informational purposes only. It is not, nor should it be taken as medical or legal advice. None of the content on this site is intended to substitute for medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment. Attorney Advertising.
We serve clients in every city and county in New York State. These include places like: The Adirondacks, Albany, Alexandria Bay, Amsterdam, Astoria, Auburn, Ballston Spa, Batavia, Beacon, Binghamton, Brooklyn, Buffalo, Canandaigua, Carthage, Cattaraugus, Catskill, Cayuga Lake, Cazenovia, Chelsea, Clayton, Clifton Park, Cobleskill, Colonie, Cooperstown, Corning, Cortland, Delhi, Delmar, Dunkirk, East Aurora, East Hampton, Elmira, Fayetteville, Finger Lakes, Flushing, Fredonia, Fulton, Garden City, Geneva, Glen Cove, Glens Falls, Gloversville, Gouverneur, Great Neck, Greenwich Village, Hamilton, Hammondsport, Harlem, Haverstraw, Hempstead, Herkimer, Hornell, Hudson, Huntington, Ilion, Ithaca, Jamaica, Jamestown, Johnstown, Kingston, Lake George, Lake Placid, Lewiston, Little Falls, Liverpool, Lockport, Long Island City, Lowville, Malone, Manhattan, Manlius, Massena, Medina, Middletown, Monticello, Montauk, Mount Vernon, New Paltz, New Rochelle, Newburgh, Niagara Falls, North Tonawanda, Norwich, Nyack, Ogdensburg, Old Forge, Olean, Oneida, Oneonta, Ossining, Oswego, Penn Yan, Peekskill, Plattsburgh, Port Chester, Potsdam, Poughkeepsie, Queens, Rhinebeck, Riverhead, Rochester, Rome, Rye, Sag Harbor, Saranac Lake, Saratoga Springs, Schenectady, Seneca Falls, Seneca Lake, Skaneateles, SoHo, Southampton, Spring Valley, Staten Island, Stony Brook, Suffern, Syracuse, Tarrytown, The Bronx, Thousand Islands, Ticonderoga, Troy, Tupper Lake, Utica, Warsaw, Waterloo, Watertown, Watkins Glen, Wellsville, White Plains, Williamsburg, Woodstock, Yonkers, and many more communities throughout New York State.
Copyright © 2026, Porter Law Group. Personal Injury Lawyers
Made with 💛 by Gold Penguin
